"But taking Java packages in one phone and putting them in another phone where the APIs do the same thing... that is not the same thing"
-
-
"And then scrubbing out a few more j's."
-
"Again, their words, not mine."
-
"Don't demonstrate to Sun employees or Sun lawyers."
-
"...they knew what they were doing was wrong. And I ask you, is THIS what innovation is supposed to be about?"
-
Now going over the fateful Mazzocchi email to the apache mailing list where he says APIs are copyrightable.
-
Poor guy went on the stand and was transparently full of regret about his emails, went full retrospective
#IANAL -
I'm not sure how the jury took it. I don't think jury got to hear that he works at Google now.
-
Huh, Oracle is pointing to Apache's lack of a license to suggest that it was also infringement.
-
Huhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
-
And if Apache Harmony is infringement, Android also infringement, etc. All independent implementations are.
-
We are about 40 mins into Bicks's hour and a half, and it's been almost entirely about embarrassing Google emails.
-
If Google didn't have the burden of proof I'd say Google has it.
-
As it is, coin flip.
-
"Wanting to win is okay. ... But not when you take shortcuts and break the rules."
-
Slide showing "The Two Faces of Jonathan Schwartz."
-
Slide shows literally two faces with different text on them.
-
One face is labeled "PUBLIC" and has a quote from the blogpost, other says "PRIVATE" and has quotes from emails.
-
Including the "Scroogle" quote. "Those were his words, not mine."
-
"It takes someone with strength and courage to stand up to Google. And that's what Oracle's done."
-
Now talking about Factor 2. Going to bang on how creative API use is.
-
Reviews how Reinhold compared API creation to Harry Potter.
-
"Very much like a book in a series. Book... title... chapter... sentence."
-
Says it was like copying the Harry Potter series, except "it was a series of 37 books."
-
Reinhold testified that there were an "infinite" number of choices in designing API packages.
-
"No different from writing a poem..."
-
Throws Bloch's own words back at Google, "This is an art, not a science"
-
"Absolutely a creative activity."
-
Oracle admits "almost all computer code is functional." However...
-
"The question here is how creative it is. Just because it does two things... doesn't take away from how creative it is."
- 2 réponses de plus
Nouvelle conversation -
Le chargement semble prendre du temps.
Twitter est peut-être en surcapacité ou rencontre momentanément un incident. Réessayez ou rendez-vous sur la page Twitter Status pour plus d'informations.