It's an exception to GPL linking — I'm going to assume my audience knows what this is and what Classpath exception is
-
-
Astrachan is now summarizing his conclusions, saying that what he found points to fair use.
-
Break time. Jury leaves room and now Oracle & Google discussing that motion in limine.
-
Oracle wants all Astrachan's testimony stricken because no mention that the use was unlicensed.
-
Alsup says it can be cured with cross-examination. "Good point, I wish I knew then what I knew now, but you can cross examine."
-
Google: There's nothing in this testimony that "this is the law." Oracle says the testimony is conflating with jury instruction.
-
Oracle has, like, a point. Astrachan bootstrapped off the Oracle employee saying Android had "transformed" the market,
-
and that doesn't have anything to do with fair use.
-
Alsup: What I'm going to do is.. I'm going to let the testimony stand, but say that the word transformative is both a legal term and...
-
... and an English word. And he is not qualified to tell us the legal meaning.
-
And that the jury must take his meaning in the more limited sense of the English word.
-
Alsup: *wearily* I can't tell people not to use English words.
-
Oracle is quick to say that this fixes things.
-
They're now arguing about something I'm not entirely sure of, re: how many classes are technically necessary for implementing Java language
-
Alsup: I don't like testimony where the witness is throwing back something that Oracle said.
-
Apparently Oracle said 61 classes were necessary, now they've changed their mind and are going with 62? Or maybe the other way around.
-
I... uh... could use a granola bar.
-
Anyways, parties are trying to come to a stipulation. Google says "We have a stipulation," Hurst (Oracle) chuckles. "Not until I see it."
-
We're in a break right now and I'm gonna wolf down said granola bar, hopefully I'll be sharper after.
-
jury is coming back. After Astrochan is done, Oracle puts on its case, starting with present CEO Safra Katz.
-
Alsup giving that admonition re: English words they discussed over the break.
-
Astrachan says developers using Java programming language expect a rich set of APIs
-
Oracle's cross begins.
-
(Yep it's Annette Hurst)
-
Oracle is questioning Astrochan on differences he's drawn between API/implementing code.
-
Oracle: Is it true that the purpose of the 37 APIs in Android is the same as in the Java platform?
-
Astrochan says that it's a different context.
-
(but — and i'm heavily paraphrasing — that functions are the same, because functionality)
-
Astrachan has been in court since last week, has heard much of the case. Oracle now asking him about other testimony in the case.
-
Oracle: Designing a good API is difficult, isn't it? Astrachan agrees. Oracle: The way being a painter or a concert artist is hard?
-
Astrachan: I think they're hard, I don't think they're hard in the same way.
- 88 réponses de plus
Nouvelle conversation -
Le chargement semble prendre du temps.
Twitter est peut-être en surcapacité ou rencontre momentanément un incident. Réessayez ou rendez-vous sur la page Twitter Status pour plus d'informations.