-
-
Both Google and Oracle are relitigating.https://twitter.com/xor/status/731165048681304065 …
-
We're going through some things that Bloch wrote. Oracle: You said here that "API design is tough" Bloch: I said it’s tough to do it *well*
-
Basically Oracle is trying to convince the jury of the labor that goes into creating APIs.
-
It's nuts, that has nothing to do with fair use OR 102(b).
-
They just think that if the jury thinks it's hard work, they're more likely to rule in Oracle's favor.
-
Oracle pointing to an email that Bloch wrote, where he says, "Oooh, you put your hand into the buzz saw."
-
Oracle: You said that because you understood that using OpenJDK in Android was a verboten topic at Google.
-
Bloch: I had said that at one point in my life, but on further reflection, I think I misspoke.
-
Now playing a 2011 depo, where Bloch explains that he wrote that email because the guy had mentioned a "verboten topic."
-
Oracle [tape]: Why did you think that was a verboten topic? Bloch: [thinking for a while]
-
Bloch says that the general sense of that they couldn't use GPL code other than the Linux kernel. (Makes sense? It's GPL?)
-
(Is the jury going to catch that GPL thing?)
-
Bloch stands by testimony, but clarifies in a "ummm actually" voice that "verboten" wasn't right word, he should have said "controversial"
-
She's reading a page out of the Java spec where Sun Microsystems gives a license on the inner leaf (didn't catch what was licensed)
-
Bloch is excused.
-
Now watching a video of a depo of Donald Smith, who worked at Oracle in 2015.
-
Google [tape]: Have you ever been deposed before? Smith: I have not. oh boy
-
oh boooooy
-
Smith is giving a deposition as a 30(b)(6) witness, meaning he is there to speak on behalf of Oracle.
-
Google: Do you understand the Java language to include the APIs? Smith: Yes, the APIs are a critical part of the language.
-
Smith: The APIs are a fundamental part of what makes Java Java, what makes a developer recognize Java.
-
Google: Do you believe that the Java language and Java APIs are inseparable? Smith: Um...I’m not sure I fully understand the context of that
-
Google: In other words, can the two be separated for the purposes of what is permissible?
-
Smith: So, again, as it relates to the specification and the language is it’s defined, no they’re not separable...
-
Smith: ...they’re all defined together under the same specification.
-
Google: Is that part of Oracle’s overall business strategy, to encourage people to write in Java programming language?
-
Smith: Yes, again, a lot of our products are based on Java. …the more that the platform is available, the better it is for us as a business.
-
Smith says there are 10+ million Java developers in the world, and their business is growing and makes lots of money. This is 2015.
-
Then the video skips ahead to the afternoon of the deposition. Smith is no longer sounding peppy. He looks a little defeated.
- 27 réponses de plus
Nouvelle conversation
Le chargement semble prendre du temps.
Twitter est peut-être en surcapacité ou rencontre momentanément un incident. Réessayez ou rendez-vous sur la page Twitter Status pour plus d'informations.