i wonder if the other two judges tried to prank leval by pretending that they thought someone else should write the opinion
-
-
Alright, finally finished. GOOD RULING. Huge. Will be assigned in every copyright law class as mandatory from here on out.
-
One thing I want to note— Google Books appears to be inconsistent with UMG v. http://Mp3.com . VERY WEIRD
-
2nd Cir of course overrides SDNY, so not like it would ever result in a circuit split, but whoa
-
I suppose in copyrightland, libraries always win and music startups always lose, but it's a marker of how far we've come since the 00s!
-
Clear limits to mass digitization in this case—though I don't think anyone was arguing for something like thispic.twitter.com/OQgPs8Yz20
-
I also love that this decision really nails what people actually use Google Books forpic.twitter.com/3UrMDDJXpy
-
The best copyright law is made by extremely unreasonable plaintiffs. Thank you, Authors Guild, for your service to the public.
-
- Fin de la conversation
Nouvelle conversation -
Le chargement semble prendre du temps.
Twitter est peut-être en surcapacité ou rencontre momentanément un incident. Réessayez ou rendez-vous sur la page Twitter Status pour plus d'informations.