I'm also concerned that the best parts of Lenz will be viewed as 9th deviancy.
-
-
Bad!Lenz is all set though.
Merci. Twitter en tiendra compte pour améliorer votre fil. SupprimerSupprimer
-
-
-
@sarahjeong Historically, 9th Cir. has been very influential in#copyright matters. I wouldn't not too concerned. -
@RickSandersLaw@sarahjeong agreed - I think other courts give at least some weight to copyright decisions coming from 2nd/9th circuits. -
@RickSandersLaw@sarahjeong or do I disagree with Rick? Double negative there, “wouldn’t not”... -
@panjwaniPK@RickSandersLaw But the 9th circuit outliers? This one's an outlier imo. -
@sarahjeong@panjwaniPK This lacks the Kozisnki-level crazy of Roommates & Garcia. This opinion isn’t that out of mainstream -
@RickSandersLaw@panjwaniPK It reminds me of grokster (9th), which was also doctrinally correct, maybe even less academically controversial -
@RickSandersLaw@panjwaniPK there's a reason why everyone's excited about "fair use is not infringement," it's because it IS noteworthy -
@RickSandersLaw@panjwaniPK definitely less of a politically charged case but I can easily imagine another circuit picking a fight - 2 réponses de plus
Nouvelle conversation -
-
-
@sarahjeong Any thoughts on the L. rev. article that was cited in the opinion? -
@djsziff I haven't gone back and reviewed the article itself but I am aware of the controversy and sympathetic to the argument -
@djsziff honestly I find it hard to think of fair use as other than an affirmative defense but if an appellate ct says so I'm happy to agree -
@sarahjeong Prof. Loren presented the paper at UW, so I read an earlier draft. I'm a complete IP novice/idiot, but it seemed solid to me. -
@sarahjeong But of course as a novice/idiot, I'm obviously missing things, so I'm reading your analysis with much interest! -
@djsziff did you read my analysis that went up last night? IDK if I'll do further analysis specifically on Lenz (9th) -
@sarahjeong Yup! Also interested in defense vs. aff. defense stuff more generally, but that's really only bc I read Prof. Loren's piece. -
@djsziff I'll definitely be reading that paper soon! Just been a little busy since the decision came out :) - 2 réponses de plus
Nouvelle conversation -
Le chargement semble prendre du temps.
Twitter est peut-être en surcapacité ou rencontre momentanément un incident. Réessayez ou rendez-vous sur la page Twitter Status pour plus d'informations.