Day 3 is underway (please mute this thread if you don't want regular updates!). @LindseyGrahamSC opens by rebutting this remark from @KamalaHarris yesterday accusing Barrett of being less forthcoming than RBG was.https://twitter.com/sahilkapur/status/1316158391472009217 …
-
-
Graham praises Barrett for being the first unashamedly pro-life woman to be nominated to the Supreme Court.https://twitter.com/JulieNBCNews/status/1316366106857213953 …
Show this thread -
Amy Coney Barrett on voting laws: "Any specific measures that legislative bodies took to protect the integrity of the ballot box could be subject to litigation, subject to challenge."
Show this thread -
Dianne Feinstein is up, noting that Amy Coney Barrett sided with the dissent in NFIB that argued the ACA was *not* severable from the individual mandate.
Show this thread -
Barrett on Obamacare and severability: "If you picture severability being like a jenga game — it's kind of if you pull one out, can you pull it out while it all stands, or if you pull two out, will it still stand?" She doesn't say if she shares Scalia's view on severability.
Show this thread -
Barrett: "Severability is designed to say, well, would Congress still want the statute to stand even with this provision gone? Would Congress have still passed the same statute without it?" Feinstein after her reply: "Thank you. That's quite a definition. I'm really impressed."
Show this thread -
Feinstein asks Barrett if she agrees with originalists like Mike Rappaport who say Medicare and Social Security are unconstitutional: https://lawliberty.org/the-unconstitutionality-of-social-security-and-medicare/ … Amy Coney Barrett says she's not familiar with the article and can't weigh in on it.
Show this thread -
Asked again if she agrees broadly with originalists who think Medicare and Social Security are unconstitutional, Amy Coney Barrett doesn't say. "I can't answer the question in the abstract," she replies, saying such a case could come before her and she hasn't seen the arguments.
Show this thread -
Dianne Feinstein sounds surprised that Amy Coney Barrett won't say Medicare is constitutional. "It's hard for me to believe that's a real question. The Medicare program is really sacrosanct in this country."
Show this thread -
Amy Coney Barrett doesn't say if Shelby County (the case that eliminated preclearance under the Voting Rights Act) was rightly decided. "Shelby County has obviously been controversial. It's likely to be re-litigated. It could come up before me on the Court," she says.
Show this thread -
Amy Coney Barrett won't say if she agrees with Antonin Scalia in 2013 that some voting rights laws reflected a "perpetuation of racial entitlement." She says it's "not something I can opine on" because it's tied into litigation surrounding the Voting Rights Act.
Show this thread -
Chuck Grassley: "Democrats want to distract from the fact that they don't really care about Obamacare. You heard that since Democrats started their presidential primaries, probably two years ago. They want government-run Medicare For All." "This is all a charade."
Show this thread -
In fact, Democrats fought a primary this year and the guy who opposes Medicare For All won in a landslide.https://twitter.com/sahilkapur/status/1316376960348696579 …
Show this thread -
"Dems don't really care about Obamacare" is one of the wildest things I've ever heard covering politics.
Show this thread -
Amy Coney Barrett says she'll keep an open mind to having cameras in the Supreme Court chamber so Americans can watch oral arguments.
Show this thread -
Dick Durbin presses Amy Coney Barrett on whether a president can unilaterally deny the right to vote based on things like a person's race. She treads cautiously: "I really can't say anything more than I'm not going to answer hypotheticals." He doesn't look pleased.pic.twitter.com/44kHC8lcgh
Show this thread -
Unlike yesterday, Sheldon Whitehouse is currently using his question time to ask the nominee questions.
Show this thread -
Sheldon Whitehouse is making the accurate (and not well understood) point that Supreme Court justices aren't bound by precedent, and can overrule precedent for any reason when a relevant lawsuit comes before them.
Show this thread -
Here
are more than 200 examples of the U.S. Supreme Court overruling precedent. The only "test" to meet is five justices have to want to do it.
https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/GPO-CONAN-2014/pdf/GPO-CONAN-2014-13.pdf …Show this thread -
After Ted Cruz faults Democrats for raising boatloads of money while bashing dark money, Sheldon Whitehouse on MSNBC invites Republicans to join his party in supporting stricter campaign finance rules like the DISCLOSE Act.
Show this thread -
Amy Klobuchar tells Barrett the Trump administration's position with the Supreme Court is to throw out the entire ACA. That's accurate. Here is the brief:https://twitter.com/sahilkapur/status/1276354916555075584 …
Show this thread -
Klobuchar to Barrett: "You will have the polar opposite judicial philosophy of Justice Ginsburg."
Show this thread -
Amy Coney Barrett: "I am aware that the president opposes the Affordable Care Act. I am aware that he has criticized the Affordable Care Act."
Show this thread -
Klobuchar asks Barrett if she's aware of Trump's positions on the ACA. She doesn't give a yes or no, and Klobuchar presses. Barrett: "You're suggesting that I have animus or that I cut a deal with the president. And I was very clear yesterday that that hasn't happened."
Show this thread -
Amy Coney Barrett gets more defensive than usual when pressed by Klobuchar about what she knew of Trump's positions on the ACA when she wrote publicly to criticize it: "To the extent you're suggesting this was like an open letter to President Trump, it was not."
Show this thread -
KLOBUCHAR: Are absentee ballots, better known as mail-in ballots, an essential way to vote for millions of Americans right now? BARRETT: That's a matter of policy on which I can't express a view. KLOBUCHAR: Ugh. To me that just feels like a fundamental part of our democracy.
Show this thread -
Amy Coney Barrett doesn't say if she agrees with Clarence Thomas that the Supreme Court should revisit First Amendment law that makes it hard for public officials to win libel lawsuits. "I can't really express a view on either NYT v. Sullivan or Justice Thomas's critique on it."
Show this thread -
Barrett won't say if the First Amendment assures a reporter's right to protect a confidential source, or if she agrees that an inability to protect sources makes reporters less likely to obtain information of importance to the public. She says these issues may come to court.
Show this thread -
Amy Coney Barrett on whether Griswold was correctly decided: "I think Griswold isn't going anywhere unless you plan to pass a law prohibiting couples or all people from using birth control... It seems unthinkable that any legislature would pass such a law."
Show this thread -
Chris Coons quotes Antonin Scalia, who Barrett has described as a mentor, dissenting in gay rights cases like Lawrence v. Texas and accusing the Court of co-signing a "homosexual agenda" when it said states cannot outlaw consensual sex between two men. From Scalia's dissent:pic.twitter.com/Ns7gVhjLCW
Show this thread -
Amy Coney Barrett is willing to say Brown v. Board of Eduction and Loving v. Virginia were correctly decided. She isn't willing to say the same about Griswold v. Connecticut, Lawrence v. Texas or Obergefell v. Hodges (doesn't say one way or the other on these cases).
Show this thread - Show replies
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.