The Gom Jabbar, in Dune, is a deeper metaphor than I realized.
-
-
The Bene Gesserit say that those who fail the test are “animals” and those who pass it are “human.”
Show this thread -
Animals, even very primitive ones like C. elegans, have something like pain and pleasure; at any rate you can use classical conditioning on them. But could any animals pass the Gom Jabbar test?
Show this thread -
(Come to think of it, that’s actually not a question with an obvious answer; prey animals like sheep can be unbelievably stoic, since noticeably injured sheep are targets to predators.)
Show this thread -
But going back to people. The question “if you could feel pure bliss and then die, or feel pure torture and then live, which would you choose?” is actually a tough one.
Show this thread -
I think evolution probably *has* selected for the ability to pass the Gom Jabbar test in humans. Iirc all modern humans passed through a drought-and-famine bottleneck. We may have needed to do counter-instinctual things to survive.
Show this thread -
It seems clear that in radically changing environments, individuals who can seek survival faster than evolution can change the reward function will have a fitness advantage.
Show this thread -
The Bene Gesserit, in Dune, were a response to technology. They thought developing this “survival intent” in people was necessary for humanity to cope with technological change.
Show this thread -
Unfortunately, Dune is fiction, not a how-to manual. We don’t know how to make humans who are all-round just better at being human. Would be cool though. Open problem.
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.