Opens profile photo
Follow
Rick Perlstein
@rickperlstein
There’s always more, and it’s always worse. But it’s never new. Writer, jazz pianist, angler, Chicagoan, political volunteer, prez of In These Times magazine.
Joined February 2009

Rick Perlstein’s posts

I just got an interview request from a reporter at an agenda-setting DC publication. It began, "I'm working on a magazine story about political buzzwords (i.e. 'critical race theory,' 'equity,' 'cancel culture,' etc.)"—then went on...
213
10.3K
Replying to
"...but products of careful propaganda campaigns to seed moral panics in order to roll back human rights for everyone who is not conservative, using techniques quite similar to Nazi propagandists..."
30
8,333
Replying to
"This also represents atrociously biased journalism. When one side is willing to lie, cheat, and steal to achieve political dominance, and the gatekeeping media represents their efforts as one 'side' in some neutral political debate..."
11
8,046
There's nothing to debate. It's a thoroughgoing fantasy. The real Hamilton was a literal plutocrat, who wanted to turn debtors into veritable vassals of a strong state, not some admirable multiculti hero.
Quote
Nearly Five Years After Hamilton's Debut, Historians Still Debate its Historical Accuracy dlvr.it/RZtFT0
Image
82
6,730
In the summer of 2009 President Obama held two meetings with historians to impart what wisdom they could about his tasks ahead. At the first, Garry Wills told him to get out of Afghanistan because it would turn into another Vietnam. He wasn't invited to the second.
72
6,301
Replying to
"his framing is horrifying to me, the sort of thing that actively contributes to the destruction of American democracy. These are not 'political buzzwords' to which liberals and conservatives 'ascribe different meanings'...
9
6,008
It will be a horrifying fascination to see how much further one of America's political parties has to advance into fascist territory before agenda-setting elite political journalists start to report that one of America's political parties is advancing into fascist territory.
144
6,272
Fed chair Jerome Powell: we need "some pain." In other words (to simplify), for people who work for wages, to help those who live on investments. When I wrote the part of my 1976-80 book REAGANLAND on Volcker doing that in 1979, I almost cried.
67
5,374
I'm starting to grow proud of this guy. It's hard to grow and change. And yet he's doing it.
Quote
Biden: "A lot of folks are losing hope ... So I'm going to act and I'm going to act fast. I would like to be doing it with the support of Republicans ... but they're just not willing to go as far as we have to go."
108
4,632
This is a foundational right-wing fantasy. Phyllis Schlafly in 1964 claimed Gallup made up poll numbers to make conservatism look unpopular. A poll found 80% of Tea Partiers said their views represented the majority of Americans. It was actually 20 percent.
Quote
There’s an extremely loud 30% of the country that’s pro-Trump, anti-choice, and anti-trans. They’ve convinced a lot of people they’re half the country but they’re not. They’re 30%. twitter.com/HeerJeet/statu…
67
4,917
Replying to
"I was wondering if you'd be willing to chat for a bit this week or next about that and how you make sense of this moment." With Eric Boehlert gone, I'm less inclined to let stuff like this slide. So I took up the invitation to "chat," with an email reading thus:
22
3,864
THIS IS AN EXTREMELY IMPORTANT TEXT TO PRESERVE AND STUDY. The refrain that "there would have been no violence had liberals not provoked it" is central to America's reactionary minoritarian traditions literally going back centuries.
Quote
Those calling for impeachment or invoking the 25th Amendment in response to President Trump’s rhetoric this week are themselves engaging in intemperate and inflammatory language and calling for action that is equally irresponsible and could well incite further violence.
65
3,288
I have friends who've spent weeks performing the equivalent of defending Germany seizing the Sudenland because of the aggression against them at Verseilles. Some serious reflection is in order.
51
3,385
Replying to
"...and how liberals and conservatives ascribe different meanings to them. I'm not as much interested in who's more 'right' about what something like 'critical race theory' means, as the ways in which the definitions differ depending on who you ask..."
20
3,087
Just hit "send" on the manuscript for the fourth and final volume in my series on the rise of American conservatism beteen 1958 and 1981. I've been working on it for twenty-two years.
121
2,690
Any normal teenager will now be desperate to figure out what this forbidden "critical race theory" thingy is now... Great job, Texas, Florida, etc.
923
2,710
Replying to
Kevin, one of my fave discoveries in research for my next book was tbe Mississippi reporter who covered an anti-ERA meeting and realized it was the same people at the White Citizens Council meetings he used to cover.
16
2,335
History final exam, Fall semester 2052: compare and contrast the political, cultural, and social effect of 3,000 deaths in New York City on September 11, 2001 in the United States to that of the 3,000 deaths every day in December of 2020.
61
2,383
As I show n NIXONLAND, Roger Ailes invented the TV "town hall" format for the 68 Nixon campaign to bamboozle the public into believing Nixon was bravely taking all comers (when actually he was getting questioned by amateurs who didn't know how to ask tough ?s + follow up).
Quote
Jim Sciutto announces CNN's Trump town hall
61
2,526
"We came out here dressed in T-shirts, using hula hoops and stuff — they started gassing us. So we came back with respirators — they started shooting us. So we came back with vests — they started aiming for the head. So we started wearing helmets. And now they call us terrorists"
13
2,181
Being a liberal, I can have nothing but compassion for the victims of right-wing energy policy in Texas, AND support a federal rescue, AND recall the ubiquitous "LET THEM FREEZE IN THE DARK" bumper stickers Texans directed at the Northeast's heating oil shortage of the late 70s.
44
2,116
It's so fascinating to me that the immediate collapse of the Afghan government is reported by braying horserace journalists as a terrible blunder by Biden, when then alternative was a slow collapse, which is to say a bloody civil war.
57
2,088
Been researching an essay about C. Everett Koop, AIDS, and the Reagan administration. One detail that pops out at this particular juncture is the lust back then to criminalize people who irresponsibly spread viruses. Not seeing a lot of that now on the right. For some reason...
43
1,990
A reporter friend in Texas wrote me of his frustration interviewing anti-"CRT" activists want, because their responses when asked what they want are so frantically incoherent. I said it's because he's touching territory incompatible with the empirical routines of journalism. 1/
36
1,903
I could try to explain the midcentury pluralism Biden and Pelosi grew up with that equated "strong two-party system" with civic health itself, but it's so alien to our reality it would be easier to explain air to a fish. Just treat it as one of those weird things old people say.
Quote
President-elect Joe Biden: "We need a Republican Party. We need an opposition that's principled and strong."
49
1,778
I would like to hear from lawyers whether the Eastman memo, in concert with Giuliani's voicemail to a senator he thought was Tommy Tuberville to "try to just slow it down" so they could arrange things with state legislatures, represents some sort of case for sedition.
21
1,707
This reminds me of the "skyrocketing" rates of divorce in the 1970s. It wasn't really true. The lion's share were marriages that had long ago functionally ended, but who could not legally get divorces because the laws previously required an elaborate finding of "fault."
Quote
Whenever I see people talking about the “skyrocketing” rates of people saying that they’re trans, I think of this chart. They used to punish children for being left-handed and force them to write with their right hand. Guess what happened after that stopped? twitter.com/JoshABlock/sta…
Image
9
1,737
Ugh, news people. Especially , with which I torture myself each morning. The debt ceiling situation is a "negotiation over federal spending" in the same way Jan 6, 2021 was a "negotiation over who should be president." Please please please stop. Please report reality.
48
1,863
Beware: a main complaint of the anon NYT op-ed is that Trump betrays the conservative revolution. It's thus part and parcel of washing plain old regular conservative movement insanity in the blood of the lamb, positioning it as Washington's respectable center.
36
1,451
Today Biden made clear he understands that the press's posture toward him as adversarial gamesmanship, and wouldn't play their game; and that he's interested in the opinions of Republican voters, not Republican elected officials betraying those voters. I thought it was great.
21
1,592
Union-busting NLRB general refused to resign, whining about fairness. Biden told him to piss up a rope, summarily firing him. Already, a far less go-along-to-get-along style being struck than under Obama.
36
1,487
I'm retiring. It took me 3,000 pages to say start this guy did in a tweet.
Quote
Ooh, I know this one! Your mythical Conservatism is a niche brand of elite narcissism incapable of winning national elections. So you used evangelicals/racists/gun nuts as electoral foot soldiers. But then--whoops!--they became self-aware and realized they don't need you. twitter.com/nytdavidbrooks…
21
1,506
If Trump, for political reasons, pushes an inadequately tested vaccine that doesn't work and causes harm, he will set back public trust of government health initiatives for generations. The harm could be incalculable. His wickedness is boundless. His enablers belong in hell.
56
1,400
So, science fiction story about a dystopian society that suffers a horrible epidemic, and slowly divided itself into a population that respects science, gets vaccinated, and stays healthy, and one that does not, and suffers horribly. Writes itself?
94
1,303
I need to emphasize the American right HAS ALWAYS BEEN THIS WEIRD. I wish I still had copies of the freaked out campaign memos trying to figure out how to simultaneously disassociate Goldwater from all the "Americans for Goldwater" or whatever independent groups claiming...
41
1,457
Open letter to press: I've given my last interview about the '68 election's lessons for 2020's. Given Trump's tweet on postponing it, the political media's determination to bound its discussion within the frame of normal politics is downright dangerous, and I won't be complicit.
18
1,198
I'm now convinced they weren't foolish. People presented evidence otherwise, and I'm conviced.
Quote
Replying to @rickperlstein
These responses are foolish. Tickets you get weeks after the event, when you were following the flow of traffic on a right-of-way with no evident speed limit signs or cameras, ARE NOT AN INCENTIVE TO DRIVE MORE SAFELY.
64
1,297
Rudy to Arizona house speaker: "Aren't we all Republicans here?" No plaimer way to say "we all know the GOP is a mafia" without saying "we all know the GOP is a mafia." This is stunning stuff.
20
1,168
For almost every invocation of "polarization" among elite commentators and journalists as the cause of our woes, the better descriptor would be "Republican authoritarianism."
23
1,261
Why is Bernie Sanders is insisting that a candidate with a plurality should get the nomination in 2020, when back in 2016 he was arguing that the super-delegates should vote against the candidate who had not just a plurality, but a majority of the elected delegates?
112
1,044
More stunning normalization of authoritarianism: "historic patterns" are the reason Dems need from 5-10 percent more votes than Republicans to win Congress--not the systematized democracy theft known as partisan gerrymandering. But you know this, .
Quote
Biden approval ticks up 5 points to 42% and Democrats catch up to GOP in generic congressional ballot, erasing 10-point gap. But historic patterns suggest Democrats need a bigger edge to hold onto majority. ⁦@danbalz⁩ ⁦@EmGusk⁩ ⁦@sfcpollwashingtonpost.com/politics/2022/
23
1,159
Replying to
What's going on is the sort of panic that it triggered when someone someone fears that, on some level, they ARE a bad person, and/or grasp that it is indeed the case that white people share collective guilt for the degradation of Black people--and find that thought intolerable.
26
1,054
Trump's conspiracy spew isn't working because it's not getting high-level mainstream media buy-in, like, say, Benghazi got high-level mainstream media buy-in, or Hillary Clinton's server. Something seems to be changing in those rarified precincts. (Fingers crossed.)
25
969
So, "critical race theory": right-wing strategists identifying, then exacerbating, local discontents about cultural change as an organizing tool has been utterly routinized for almost 50 years. THAT'S THE STORY! Yet somehow it comes off as novel each and every time.
Image
31
1,030
The most famous Dem economic advisor says rich speculators who had the poor judgement to deposit in an untrustworthy bank have to be made whole. Nothing about the moral hazard this presents, nor the message to the proles who only get $250K in protection.
71
1,122
Replying to
The entire civilization of the antebellum South was built upon managing this. Obviously, the people building it knew their economy a rapeocracy. Thereupon, they framed their world as the apogee of refinement. The alternative--true--was psychologically intolerable.
22
992
To end a day when I kept getting lectured for insufficient reverence toward the leadership of the Democratic Party past and present, just asking: did You know Bill Clinton just addressed a crypto conference in the Bahamas hosted by Anthony Scaramucci?
Quote
Truly an honor to introduce and welcome former President @BillClinton and former Prime Minister Tony Blair to @CryptoBahamas to cap off an incredible Day 3.
Image
28
1,029
Fox is fun right now. Ken Starr complaining that Roger Stone was merely convicted of a "process crime." You know, lying to before an official body. Which he's apparently totally cool with now?
59
906
One's anti-racist education can never truly end. This is a quote from a National Association of Real Estate Broker textbook from the 1940s. From a stunning book I'll be blurbing called "Freedom to Discriminate: How Realtors Conspired to Segregate Housing and Divide America"...
Image
43
1,003
Howto: like the Senate Watergate Committee, slowly building case witness by witness, starting at the bottom, saving principles for last when the evidence is in the record (and on TV). And deliberately tie in as many co-conspirators, including McConnell and Pence, as possible.
29
912
When I heard Putin was calling up 300,000 reservists, I immediately thought of how DESPERATELY Lyndon Johnson fought to keep from calling up reservists, to hide the scale of the debacle in Vietnam. Russia may well and truly be fucked.
35
976
It's so patronizing and counterproductive for Joe Biden to implore Republicans to "follow your conscience," as if they're not already--as if they don't sincerely believe liberalism will lead to the ruin of civilization, and that conscience dictates giving it no safe harbor, ever.
59
902
Replying to
When a teacher says --"I taught your child that housing discrimination in the past makes white people wealthier than Black people in the present"--and respond, "STOP INDOCTRINATING MY CHILD THAT BLACK PEOPLE ARE BETTER THAN WHITE PEOPLE?", what is going on?
9
932
I've been listening to a lot of right-wing talk radio yesterday and today. All take it as a given that Democrats have stolen the election, and, with the feckless Republican establishment having stood down, successfully.... 1/
62
902
It's painful to me. During one of history's greatest opportunities to teach fellow citizens about how social solidarity works and why it is imperative, young leftists are consuming themselves in petty vendettas over political personalities.
52
866
I learned something fascinating writing REAGANLAND: the gas shortages in '79 were SMALL. Lines were largely caused by what I called a "run on the tanks": whenever people passed a gas station that was open, they filled up. Fighting this, then and now, is a leadership problem.
41
899
Just watched James Carville say (quoting cuz I checked!) he never thought the GOP would get to a point where they "limit the number of people who vote...This is a radical change in American politics." He must be new to American politics. Dem establishment = lamest establishment.
49
857
Replying to
The elite media analysis of black and white evidence of a coup attempt is almost exclusively "how will this play in the swing states" or "who's winning the messaging war" diarrhea. This is how republics die. I can't begin to express my shame.
12
922
Read decision-makers, one after the other, wishing now they'd done exactly what liberals and leftists were saying they should have done then. Kind of like what you'd hear 20 years after 1965-66. Imagine if they'd just listen to us when it matters.
41
811
Missing from Afghanistan discussion: the consequences of sending thousands of young people to do the dirty work of domination, the moral injury and trauma that results (including from drone operators), and the role this surely plays in intensifying fascist tendencies at home.
33
796
My next book, with + editor —on what has happened to America since 2000, and how it can unhappen. Short, sharp, and out in time for the 2024 Democratic and Republican National Conventions. And it will take no prisoners. Now leave me alone for 18 months!
Image
50
812
Also the host saying Ashli Babbitt shot "trying to climb out a broken window." Like East Germany saying the Berlin Wall was built to keep clamoring West Germans out instead of the reverse.
Quote
Replying to @atrupar
Trump on who shot Ashli Babbitt: "I've heard also that it was the head of security for a certain high official. A Democrat. It's gonna come out."
44
788