From what I seen and the research I've done, there's more evidence that a person can come to believe that they're trans/gender dysphoric because of trauma and/or social forces than there is evidence that trauma or social forces can make someone trans/gender dysphoric.
-
-
...promotes the views of the group, get support to deal their dysphoria using "alternative treatments" rather than transition, etc. In the detrans spaces I was in, I was encouraged to examine social factors that supposedly made me trans but not social influences that could...
Show this thread -
...push a person to detransition. When I started wondering if my detransition and conversion to radical feminism could be related to trauma I experienced in the queer/trans scene, the detrans woman I was closest to didn't want to hear it and got upset and dismissive.
Show this thread -
I was encouraged to see my transition as a trauma response/reaction to social influences but wasn't supposed to critically examine my detransition in the same way. I wasn't supposed to question my detransition or evaluate whether it was really working for me.
Show this thread -
So you have a detrans community that encourages people to adopt certain views and stories about themselves, how they became trans, transitioned, etc but discouraged them from changing their minds or coming to other ways of seeing things. You can get a lot of emotional support...
Show this thread -
...and praise for telling those stories, not just from detrans and desisted women but from rad fems and others anti-trans people. It seems pretty similar to how a lot of ex-gay groups work, where you also find people adopting the stories and theories promoted by the group...
Show this thread -
...in exchange for emotional support and a sense of belonging. The longer I'm out, the more skeptical I become of detrans theories and methods. I've met some detrans/desisted people who aren't ideological and talk about how trauma or social factors played a role in why they...
Show this thread -
...thought they were trans without projecting their stories onto all trans people. I'm far more inclined to believe what they say than detrans people who are still struggling w/ dysphoria while holding anti-trans views, who seem to be talking themselves out of being trans.
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.