Robert Stoller, transphobic psychoanalyst, thought transmasculinity was caused by an afab child developing too close of a relationship with their father, while developing a distant relationship with their mother. He summed it up as "Too much father, not enough mother".
-
-
Stoller didn't have much hope in "curing" adult trans people, since he thought gender identity became fixed after a certain point and also watched most attempts to "cure" people through therapy fail. He thought it might work on kids though.
Show this thread -
Transphobic rad fems have more faith in their methods and do seem to have more "success" but they have the advantage of being a political cult that can give people a feeling of belonging, group praise and a sense of purpose one typically doesn't get from therapy.
Show this thread -
They also tolerate more gender nonconformity than heterosexist psychoanalysts, encouraging transmasculine people to live as butch lesbians or otherwise GNC women rather than as feminine straight women.
Show this thread -
Their methods can't actually "cure" a transmasculine person though, just help them live with their dysphoria as a woman. The group support and encouragement from other detrans women and rad fems plays a big role in helping people stick with it.
Show this thread -
And detrans transmasculine people are given an important role in what's supposed to be a larger struggle between women and the "trans cult" and/or "gender industry". They're told they're helping to save lesbian culture or taking down big Pharma or whatever.
Show this thread -
This is their "alternative treatment" for gender dysphoria, giving people a group to belong to, praise, and a sense that they're doing something meaningful, in exchange for choosing to "manage" one's dysphoria instead of living as a trans person.
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
Veeeerrrrry similar to many homophobic nurturist ideas (don’t let boys play w/ dolls or wear pink/don’t let girls play w/ boys or cars …”cuz it will turn m gay/lesbian”)
-
Yup. The psychoanalytic theories about what "makes people trans" and the theories that "reparative therapists" came up with to explain what "makes people gay" are pretty much the same.
- Show replies
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.