Client Charlie tells Broker Bob to procure him a share of Google, currently trading at $100 a share. Technologists think "Bob now races Charlie to the market." This is not the classical understanding of frontrunning. No. Bob buys one share immediately.
-
-
Show this thread
-
Bob then waits "a little while" and sees what happens to Google. If Google goes up to $100.15, Bob tells Charlie: "Good news, I got you a share at $100.15" and fulfills that share with the share Bob bought at $100. If Google goes to $99.85, Bob tells Charlie: "Got it at $100."
Show this thread -
Broker Bob thereby gets to play short-term speculation with his client's capital at risk and no material chance of loss. The underlying theft is not because Bob was faster, it was because Bob was willing to lie about Bob's intentions after the fact.
Show this thread -
From this follows pretty automatically "Front-running is at 2019 at an all time low because computers are really good at keeping accurate paper trails." Technologists think it is close to an all-time high because high-frequency computers make it easier to race clients / etc.
Show this thread -
Note that this frontrunning also structurally requires an informational asymmetry (Charlie can't know what the true price of Google was with sufficient resolution to catch Bob on the lie), which is something which computers/open feeds/etc work to substantially mitigate.
Show this thread -
When people propose e.g. "You need to let large positional traders somehow execute their trades without exposing this fact to other market participants, or they will be 'front run'", they are proposing substantially rolling back effective front-running protection mechanisms.
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
I think this is different to the techniques ascribed to high frequency traders in Michael Lewis' Flash Boys. It seems that HFTs pay exchanges to create order types that allow them better information / access than non-exchange-paying investors.
-
...IIRC when those were proposed, all of us at the fintech company I worked for at the time went, “huh, that sounds illegal,” so it was no surprise when the SEC banned them a year or two later
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
I always understood frontrunning as trading ahead of a large trade you happen to know about. Wikipedia and Investopedia agree: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Front_running …
-
Is what you described the same as "insider trading?"
- 1 more reply
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.