Note this doesn’t mean human capital isn’t a thing... it’s just not really a thing from undergrad. (It’s not terribly difficult to pick up signal on “Has worked at Google/similar” from a discussion of e.g. scaling.)
-
-
Show this thread
-
Curious about the Japanese pedagogy sidenote? How it is taught almost everywhere: memorize these word lists and associated symbols. How it is taught at schools which adopted Japanese: the Spoken Language (a textbook): “Drill the }^}*#*{* out of these conversations.”
Show this thread -
If universities were actually meaningfully in charge of human capital they’d definitely choose “drill the ^}*{%+{ out of it” and greater than 5% of undergrad majors in Japanese would achieve sufficient fluency to have a status meeting but they aren’t so they don’t and they don’t.
Show this thread -
“My that’s... robust.” Look at US pass rates for the JLPT test at any level, probably focusing on JLPT 3 (which tops out at approximately una cerveza por favor levels of fluency and is the theoretical goal of US undergrad instruction at most places for non-heritage majors).
Show this thread -
Japanese is a useful field for this subject because undergrads in the US who are not heritage speakers in it or Chinese are unlikely to have meaningful pre-university experience and you can’t simply IQ your way through a Japanese test.
Show this thread -
Also benefits from being tough to mistake incompetence for competence or to paper over it for social reasons. (Quoth teacher of mine: “There is no partial credit! The document does not care if you are literate or not! It will not rewrite itself to be easier since you’re trying!”)
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
The fact you repeatedly mention Waterloo as an exception is the highest praise I've ever heard for that institution
Thanks. Twitter will use this to make your timeline better. UndoUndo
-
-
-
CMU, Claremont Colleges are exceptions, it seems they'll actually fail people who fail. It's less "technology", more ... instinct
-
Yeah, CMU specializes in stuff that can be judged but not taught - CompSci, architecture, drama. They can't (mostly) teach any more than other universities, but they can fail the people who don't know it.
- 1 more reply
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.