post-pub seems great to me, but i hadn't thought about anonymity being important w.r.t URM.
-
-
It's a very well known problem that people behave differently with women and other URM names
-
This is very true. WRT to peer review, I favour reviewer-blinded to prevent retaliation. If someone uses anon to be a jerk Editor can fix it
-
do you think reviewer blinding can work? i identified every reviewer of my last paper by their writing style
-
I think this is a common criticism of blinding, but it will be a smaller problem for those newer to the field/those with less power
-
Ie. you recognise the "big wigs" easier than you would a PhD student. So, it may be real, but I'm not convinced it's harmful
-
also, if you're really concerned about being recognize you can probably purposely obfuscate yourself
-
Certainly can say I've helped people with that. Change their writing style.
- 1 more reply
New conversation -
-
I've had numerous lengthy conversations with
@Protohedgehog and others on this
-
And I'm happy to have these constructive discussions but in all honesty, Jon has been really defensive @ me in the past re these topics
-
And I'm genuinely not wanting to be combative, but you can see how that makes me reluctant now
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.