currently 1 on the go....ain't easy
-
-
-
gathering data or writing up?

-
/writing up
-
same here but going through reviews and rewrites on my own. Although rejected, I feel like I shouldn't give up yet, not sure tho.
-
Keep trying & my advice for the future: always submit replication studies as a Registered Report. Makes life much easier!
-
even for computational modelling? I guess you are telling me that in any case it makes work more publication worthy?
-
Oh yes, def for comp modelling. Works for any discipline, & imo it's not so much that RRs are more pub worthy but that >
-
> by obtaining provisional acceptance in advance, you avoid risk of rep study being rejected based on the results.
- 21 more replies
New conversation -
-
-
we've published a paper mostly dealing with replication https://arxiv.org/abs/1601.00181
-
where did you publish? Or just preprint for now?
-
Cohen, N. & Pasechnik, D.V. Des. Codes Cryptogr. (2016). doi:10.1007/s10623-016-0264-x
-
are things like this easy in your field?
-
http://wstein.org/papers/talks/2016-06-sage-bp/bp.pdf … is a good story to see how things are in my field wrt software.
-
why do these slides ring a bell...
@drvinceknight have you spoken to me about this? -
oooh right
@pydatalondon – that's where I must have seen a similar talk by Travis Oliphant.
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
Many of my expmts contain replication conditions (not always 100% exact but I don't that's so critical in those cases).
-
all of mine do pretty much, it's just that many don't replicate – been a long hard road.
-
I have discovered 6+ comp model exps that do not replicated as described, although some eventually replicate with "new" methods.
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
Currently working on getting 1 off the ground
-
Did the original author(s) knock it out of your hands like a big stack of books?
-
haha...no, thankfully not at all. Just lacking an avenue for it thus far.
-
a journal?
-
so many rejections or just not found the right one more broadly?
-
a mix of rejections & lack of established avenues at subdiscipline-specific journals.
-
I am so sorry to hear this. Is it a failure to replicate? Have you considered preprints?
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.