I don't get why it shouldn't be retracted in your opinions? Or am I misreading? 
-
-
OK. So we retract 5.000.000 papers where the Type 1 error rate was not controlled. And then? Start anew?
-
Sounds good to me! I'm glad we're agreed on that :)
-
I'm just glad you care so much about Type 1 error rates :)
-
LOL how did we go from a single person admitting they are wrong in a single pub to 5,000,000 papers being retracted?
-
Almost everything that is not pre-registered is p-hacked to some extent.
-
That's a very strong philosophical position that actually plays little role here where the authors explicitly admit.
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.