6/ These are often just repetitions of same arg's or a form of bargaining where a sceptic poses increasingly specific/unlikely cases as args
well, I'm not sure about other modellers ofc. Everybody has their own perspective. I doubt they disagree tho.
-
-
with modelling reproduction and reimplementation is v important with respect to theory/validation etc
-
In principal I stand by "pre-reg everything", but if you're not collecting new data, it's a promise no-one can check
-
model is implementation of theory imho so I could preregister a theory, but the point is to discover the theory
-
Sure but there are tons of details in a model that can be tweaked and will lead to cap. on chance if done post hoc.
-
hence why you publish the specificatiom
-
speciation captures theory, so like a preregistration which can then be tested like usual for empirical data
-
Pre-reg is just an easy way to make your specification public and safeguard against post-hoc changes.
-
it's part of a school of thought just like anyth is. There's no single scientific method http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/scientific-method/ …
- 17 more replies
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.