It's tiring sometimes talking to phd students. So many think that eg preprints promote scooping, or writing papers well is upsetting... 
yep somb actually said that going through feedback is pointless because it's upsetting and most papers are badly writen anyway
-
-
That's even hard to be tkn srsly.They can contribute to a higher ratio of well > badly written papers thmslvs; & life is suffering.
-
that's phd students with little guidance for you...
-
that's horrifying; real damage.
-
and this was not in my lab btw but I've heard similar within it
-
unsupervised phd students are not uncommon, haha..
-
I think combination of very naive and overconfident so everything they didn't know was on show including their assumptions
-
this is orthogonal to good/bad supervision, which is also probably bad in this case like you say
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
ouch that's depressing and rather arrogant - can be hard to get feedback but it's essential!
-
you should adjust the feedback to level of PhD student - and the person..
-
of course feedback needs to be good quality & appropriate
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.