I'm wondering: if I use someone else's data in my paper, should they be co-author? And if someone uses my model in their paper, should I be co-author? What about if all my analyses use brms? Should @paulbuerkner and @mcmc_stan always be co-authors?
-
-
It’s not a total order or contest. I’m trying to explain why experimentalists are often a bit...protective of data—it feels like there’s a lot more room for things to go randomly and catastrophically wrong at any moment, wiping out all our effort so far.
-
It would take years and $$$ to recover from a few TB bacteria in the animal house. OTOH, barring a worldwide collapse, I can reboot all of our analysis and modeling stuff with a ‘git clone’ and a coffee.
-
Recovering code isn't the same as recovering computational experiments nor the same as publishing them. All I asked is why people think modelers are harming you, it's not zero sum AFAIK, when it's modelers who are at a disadvantage in terms of authorship and recognition?
-
Why do non-modelling people feel the need for example to tell me that modelling is easy? When they are probably from the same group who say modelling is hard? Why? I don't say anything is easy about data collection.
-
Again, it’s not the difficulty level. BOTH ARE HARD. It’s the level of control. If your code is hard to debug, that’s on you—you wrote it! If you have a hard time publishing something, you picked the topic. Exp have these problems too, obviously.
-
I still don't get it. Why are non-modellers always behaving like it's zero sum? Also... all debugging is hard and not all code is single-developer code.
-
We are talking about *authorship*, it should be obvious that whoever builds a model authors it, that authorship does not rely on the difficulty or riks entailed in a task. However, and talking as both empirical (animal) scientist and modeller, I don't think that
-
using others' models, data or methods directly qualifies someone as co-author. IMO, it would depend on their implication on that specific study. Your research is not an investment in others'
- 7 more replies
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.