> At some point along the continuum the benefits of documentation would start to pale against the cost of managing and reading all of that information. As scientists we're all making choices about which of our nonviable ideas are worth discussion and this is healthy for the field
-
-
Nobody can say how those two tweets should be interpreted. You're saying they are not how I read them. Tell us how you read them.

-
That all work should be published (it says that explicitly) but that if there is a place for journals and pre-pub peer review it is providing the administrative infrastructure for RRs (which aren’t only for confirmatory testing).
-
Many people have clarified these points to you now, including several on the thread you linked to.
-
You are pretty clearly being disingenuous with your bad-faith take that this is some sort push to impose confirmatory testing on everyone, since you’ve kept going with that interpretation even when people have explicitly said it isn’t and have explained what it is.
-
I can see how you might have equated ‘journal’ with ‘publish’ and ‘RR’ with ‘confirmatory’ without pausing for thought, but persisting with that reading of it when people have clarified those misunderstandings isn’t helpful.
-
I think our misunderstandings are way deeper. Those are not the differences in our readings from my perspective. Firstly, I thought you all loved Popper? So falsificationism is more your thing, right? Secondly, are you saying publish is being inclusive of preprints? Can't tell.
-
I find it very amusing you think I'm arguing in bad faith but can't ascribe a motive. Bad faith REQUIRES a motive. What is my motive? https://twitter.com/Ben_C_J/status/1065175996549267456 …
This Tweet is unavailable. -
From the first tweet in the thread you highlighted: “Journals are now exclusively for registered reports, everything else is published as preprint” That couldn’t be clearer that published includes preprint (it literally says ‘published as preprint’).
- 31 more replies
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.
