What is the most insane comment you’ve gotten in a peer review? I was told never to discuss effect size (results are either significant or not). However, @Chrismartin76 may have me beat. https://twitter.com/Chrismartin76/status/1029815128894713857 …
-
-
I’m so sorry. That’s awful.
-
It made me question a lot of things, especially since nobody said that was bad really, my PI didn't seem to think we needed to discuss it and the Action Editor and my PI didn't think this was in any way unprofessional. Like you can decide not to send us the reviewers words...
-
If I were the editor I’d have serious words with that reviewer

-
Ironically, AFAIK I have met this guy 3 times, the reviewer. He doesn't remember me between times, he doesn't connect my name to the published paper, and he actually likes me every time.
-
By AFAIK, I mean I am guessing who it was.
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.
