I can't prove it for ALL texts because the manuscript tradition and other modes of transmission are ALWAYS different. Is there a particular author/group of authors you have in mind? Plato for example?
And the versions contained in these papyri, which are attestations of a much earlier MS tradition, often the Alexandrine edition, are the SAME as those we own from the 10th century. This goes to show the great quality of the MSS we own, even in the 10th century.
-
-
And this in turn should lead us to believe that if the Byzantine were able to preserve such a great manuscript tradition for over 700 years, the tradition in Antiquity, from Aristotle down to Alexandria, thence down to papyri, must have been even better.
-
And right now, we're discussing one the worse manuscript preservations of Ancient Greece. Our Homer is virtually flawless. Our Plato is excellent. Even minor authors benefited from an excellent preservation.
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.