As it should be for all journals. All. Journals.https://twitter.com/PsychScience/status/953675782429331456 …
-
Yes, and related challenges can emerge when history matters--eg., an national intervention for economic policy. "Replication" may be limited to assessing reproducibility of the gathered data, and conceptual analogue studies of evaluating the claims.
I've worried a bit about the Higgs and similar discoveries for related reasons. Although "replicated" in some limited sense, there is of course a central point of failure - one accelerator, & I believe two detectors now.
-
-
The analysis is, of course, enormously complex. An external audit of the software found thousands of (mostly trivial) bugs. But one wonders if there's something subtle in, say, one of the numerical libraries that makes a difference.
-
Just saw an interesting-looking paper (from a couple of days ago) suggesting the negative impact of centralized collaboration on replication: https://arxiv.org/abs/1801.05042 pic.twitter.com/k2SLdH9qu5
- 3 more replies
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.