michael_nielsen

My anecdotal impression :). I have had 7 arxiv papers, only got serious feedback through the formal review process.

Also, most of the arxiv papers in my field that are quickly discussed and tested come from very established last authors.

(and i say most, but can't actually think of example to the contrary)

Do the publications in high-profile journals often come from relative unknowns?

I see your point. I think that relative unknowns are much more likely to get good feedback on their work through the formal process.

Will a brilliant paper/idea surface regardless of submission to journal? I think that's very likely...

But finding better ways to democratize feedback might help the not-quite-developed precursor idea to the brilliant idea...

AFAICT just asking for feedback will often get it. A friend with no (undergrad) degree started sending thoughtful emails to senior