Perpetual mass immigration ensures the impossibility of a stable identity. Even patriotic immigrants cannot be expected to care about George Washington. One day no one will. One day no one will care about FDR, JFK, or MLK. It's inevitable with a forever-rotating population.
Things in Japan have to change, no doubt, but replacing the Japanese people with African or European or other people seems like it should be near the bottom of the list of possible solutions.
-
-
In European countries, especially the Anglosphere, and extra-specially America, mass immigration has become more of a religious belief than a mere economic solution.
-
And the US has never had a stable enthnic identity and the economic hardships that restricted immigration/falling population would run counter to the economic prosperity at the heart of the concept of the USA
-
I'm not concerned with ethnic identity, but with how to maintain and value a shared story. A country with permanent mass immigration lives in a perpetual present with history falling over the horizon every generation or two.
-
So is there an amount of immigration that still maintains the story but allows the dynamism immigration brings?
-
What worked for us in the past was a generation-long rush of mass immigration followed by a generation-long break. But we no longer have a continent to fill and certainly don't need more people. Would love to see us gradually back the population down to 300 million or so.
-
That immigration itself brought the dynamism, rather than that we had an empty continent and lots of opportunities, seems to me part of the religious belief. Postwar Japan, Germany since 1870, etc were plenty dynamic without immigration. Not convinced of causal link.
-
Very interesting thoughts. Lots to think about. Now when are we getting another Martyrmade episode???
-
Been traveling non stop for work for months. As soon as I get a week at home I'll record it.
- 1 more reply
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.