Hector Martin

You're assuming the "will of the Catalonian people" must be respected over the will of all Spanish people. That's not a foregone conclusion.

Are you telling me that the will of Spanish people must prevail over the will of Catalonian people? For real?

That's kind of how most countries are set up. Otherwise all constitutions would have a "anyone can leave" clause.

No, actually, is the opposite. Most countries got their independence against the will of the "host" country. Like, almost always.

Also, you can put your words on perspective: USA got their independence illegally, as it was against the will of the Brits. C'mon!

Exactly - in armed revolutions. But this isn't an armed revolution, it's a referendum. That doesn't work without support from the host.

If only Catalans were armed this would be Syria dude. No one would want that.

Actually, they are half-armed. But they do not want a military conflict. Indeed, it would be Spain who would start such a thing.