This is obviously a bit facetious but it's kind of a fun question! Disclaimer: I am not an options trader, especially not energy options, in fact I barely understand options at all, so everything I say here may be completely wrong. https://twitter.com/volmagorov/status/1412236522661855232 …
-
-
You can then use a Black75 options pricer to get implied vols. I used a time to expiry of six months because I couldn't be bothered to do the date math but uh I guess you should do it properly. The numbers look plausible to me but it's always possible I messed it up, not sure
pic.twitter.com/6iERzX3lYW
Show this thread -
Now you have implieds for each option you can calculate Black deltas. By "OTM option" let's assume 25 delta which looks like it's about an 80 strikepic.twitter.com/xL9blKceza
Show this thread -
The pnl for a teeny tiny move in spot is delta * spot_move + vega * vol_move (ignoring gamma, theta etc) which tells you that for the change in vol to offset the spot movement, the vol needs to move by -delta*spot_move/vega.
Show this thread -
Here's what that looks like for a +$1 move in spot, at different strikes. At the 80 strike, the vol needs to drop by 1.2% to offset the gain from the spot movepic.twitter.com/wXDgpHL2Uk
Show this thread -
(Actually its a bit more than this because I ignored gamma but w/e)
Show this thread -
The vol surface is pretty flat around the 80 strike so skew is not really playing a role here (for an ATM option there would be a skew effect, where IV mechanically drops as spot increases, because you roll up the vol surface in strike space)
Show this thread -
BUT the negative skew (puts > calls) implies a negative relationship between price and vol, i.e. all else equal you expect vol to drop when price rises, just like with stocks. So a 1.2% vol drop on a $1 price rise is not crazy at all
Show this thread -
Hence the question -- if I buy OTM calls and spot moves up $2, how much money have I lost? :)
Show this thread -
That's it for this round of
#learninginpublic, now@volmagorov can explain all the ways I screwed it up.Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.