Poll: Suppose the U.S. government raised funds w/ a special treasury security that pays a coupon guaranteed to be equal to the aggregate dividend of the S&P 500. Right now, that's ~$14 per quarter, $56 for the year. What price would the treasury security trade at?
Think you’re answering based on the security paying principal x dividend yield of the index, whereas original question assumes that the security just pays the $ value of the dividends (ie if SPX falls, the coupon is reduced). Only way I can reconcile the difference of opinion.