Sometimes Job 19 just HITS you and it's like OH GOD THE FEELS. And then you bump into Job 24:1 and it's like SERIOUSLY WHY.
-
-
God is not teaching Job. God is not improving Job. God is not helping Job. There is not a higher logic. There is merely The Fall. The absolute disordering of God's world. And when God shows up, He does not endorse any theodicy offered, not accuse Job of sin.
Show this thread -
He simply asserts HIS CREATIVENESS. He appeals to Creation! Because that's the correct argument! We see "were you there when..." as merely about cowing Job. But it isn't! It's an actual argument! God is saying: I DID NOT MAKE IT THIS WAY.
Show this thread -
And when God reveals His power, we see Him as revealing it against Job, even though God appears to be most directly and immediately responding to *Elihu* to a first approximation, and then *turns* to Job.
Show this thread -
But even if that reading is wrong, the key point is that God rebuke's Job's *presumption* but does not actually endorse any of the theodicies offered. Nor does God offer any justification for His actions.
Show this thread -
God simply says: BEHOLD MY POWER AND CREATIVENESS. He invites Job to step into the court of judgment, *and Job blinks*. But I think not because Job has now identified some theodicy at work or some sin in himself, but because he has understood his mistake.
Show this thread -
Job, like the others, expects some kind of orderly justice. He expects vindication. He expects to have a moral order revealed. But God's response is: THERE IS NO ORDER IN A BROKEN CREATION. Creation was orderly. This world is not.
Show this thread -
Also lest you think my argument is flippant: God literally in the last chapter, we often forget, turns around and talks TO JOB'S FRIENDS, and says, basically, "You absolute idiots. Job was correct in everything he said. Go and do some penitence you complete disgraces."
Show this thread -
Like I feel we don't acknowledge enough that the story ends by God saying, "EVERYTHING JOB SAID ABOUT ME WAS TRUE"
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
This is a great thread. Where can I sign up to your bible study.
Thanks. Twitter will use this to make your timeline better. UndoUndo
-
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.