fiction is distinguished from nonfiction for a reason, & we continuously frame it as such. we use fiction to say certain things about the world, and it allows for devices like unreliable narration, which don't fly in a personal essay. the collapse of that is... distressing!
-
-
Show this thread
-
i think many ppl are unused to reading contemporary fiction that isn't "booky" / that reads like a narrative essay, but the trouble with conflating the two is that our expectations for fiction are VERY DIFFERENT from that of essays.
Show this thread -
when you treat a short story like a personal essay, you end up in a weird place where you ask for morality from characters, rather than considering the architecture of the story, its devices, and its world. instead of thinking critically about it, you're asking it for lessons.
Show this thread -
i think this directly stems from the (very bad) IS X FEMINIST?!?!? school of criticism, which is a terrible way to read text. anyway, i have no takeaway here except to suggest that we all become better, more critical readers and also CAT PERSON IS A SHORT STORY NOT AN ARTICLE
Show this thread -
wait one last thing: when you write and publish in a specific form, you are entering into a contract with the reader. choosing to write fiction means we as readers agree to read the text as fiction. this distinction is crucial to how we understand text! we ought to consider it!
Show this thread -
ok i have a review to finish and i have been tweeting too much today already BYEEEEEEE
Show this thread -
uhhhh also hi if you intend on using this tweet thread in your creative writing seminars / workshops or god forbid you embed these in something...... my paypal is http://paypal.me/lrsphm and feel free to hire me to write criticism!!
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
I've seen people (who liked it) calling it an essay too
-
conflation of fiction with reality is often a problem readers have w/ realist fiction, but calling it an article or nonfiction is a whole other (strange) thing. i am fascinated.
-
Not sure if this is the same thing, but when teaching undergrad my students tend to completely interchange "story" "essay" and "article" no matter what we're reading
-
i am...... so stressed out by this
-
here come dat boi (the internet) flattening discourse once again
- 1 more reply
New conversation -
-
-
“Piece” isnt so bad. Art, paintings, sculpture, etc are referred to as “pieces” all the time.
-
agreed. i refer to a short story as a "piece" all the time and have heard many other writers do the same
- 1 more reply
New conversation -
-
-
Poor readership when folks try to act like a work of fiction is nonfiction. So suffocating as a writer
Thanks. Twitter will use this to make your timeline better. UndoUndo
-
-
-
i also see people correlating thoughts of the protagonist with thoughts of the author???
Thanks. Twitter will use this to make your timeline better. UndoUndo
-
-
-
oh - I genuinely didn't know it was fiction but it read very weirdly to me and i honestly related to it a lot, I think most women (?) have had something similar. Makes sense tho
-
And now i see the big fat fiction section header at the top....! I read it on my phone before, my eye just wasn't drawn to it, but I definitely recognised something was 'off'. You're absolutely right tho
- 1 more reply
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.