This boils down to the suggestion to lay out some premises. Isn't that a non-starter?
-
But the objection could be extended to what you call 'argumentative moves', I dare to guess.
but it also doesn’t feel like a response to my post, which really wasn’t focused on outlining premises.My current worry is that this seems too perfect-as-enemy-of-good. Arguments would seem to favour doing best we can, even if imperfect.
-
-
Maybe what irritates me is that the text conveys (to me!) idea of clarity as absolute norm - and I would think that it is audience-dependent
-
Ah,, follow link in first paragraph regarding clarity, I don’t at all think that, but wasn’t entering into it there because focus elsewhere.
- Show replies
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.