Conversation

ziwi
@lynz_h55
This is assuming one believe thats human consciousness is explained by material phenomena and the laws of nature. In which case, after many rolls of the die, your number is certain to come up again
1
ziwi
@lynz_h55
My personal position is that i say ‘unfortunate’ but that’s only because of the inevitable suffering implicit in the universe. I do think these theories are likely to be true
1
ziwi
@lynz_h55
It’s obviously a very crude analysis to say multiverses = ‘me’ coming into existence again. But it’s actually a very difficult thing to conclude what makes me, ‘me’. I.e if a replica (to the atom) of me were created on earth, would i feel as if i were that replica too?
1
antoine sugar
@joedan346
I don't think those multiverse "theories" are really theories. They may be a hypothesis. Or speculation. And, there is no "me" or "you". "You" is just a word, a linguistic fiction devised to facilitate language.
1
ziwi
@lynz_h55
Agreed. But then it logically follows there isn’t really a *sufferer*. It would just be as fictitious as the concept of ‘I’. Antinatalism rests on suffering being *real*. Otherwise one could propose that the solution to suffering is the realisation that there is no sufferer
1
antoine sugar
@joedan346
For me, antinatalism rests on the fact of existence being an imposition. No "self" is now a fact of modern neuroscience. See Thomas Metzinger & Sam Harris. David Hume, 18th century Scottish philosopher talked about it, as did others.
1
antoine sugar
@joedan346
But, you are correct. No self doctrine is taught in Adaita Vedanta & also in Buddhist philosophy, known as 'anatta'. Suffering is subjective. Suffering & pain are not the same thing. It does seem to help the suffering if it is understood that no "one" exists.
1
ziwi
@lynz_h55
Replying to
@joedan346
Is there anything interesting you have to say on the topic of reincarnation. I know in advaita they postulate a subtle body which transmigrates, but this is only apparent and not fundamentally real. Karma, reincarnation are at vyavaharika level (transactional reality) not absolut
1
antoine sugar
@joedan346
I don't know of any Advaita masters who taught reincarnation. See Ramana Maharshi or Nisargadatta Maharaj. As there is no self, there is no one to reincarnate.
1
Show replies