"What lessons should we draw? One might be that the enactivist re-descriptions can't do the work they are trying to do. If anything is a representing, computational mechanism, a chess computer is. [...]
-
-
এই থ্রেডটি দেখান
-
[...] And so, if it can be re-described in the same enactivist language that is employed as a cudgel against representationalism, then so much the worse for that cudgel."
এই থ্রেডটি দেখান -
"A very different lesson would be that even in the case of an old-fashioned chess computer, we are missing something important if we insist on conceiving it narrowly as a self-contained computational system. [...]
এই থ্রেডটি দেখান -
[...] If we need to bring in social dynamical factors, issues related to its power-consuming embodiment, and so forth to fully understand the Novag Primo, then how much stronger are those lessons when the topic is human cognition?"
এই থ্রেডটি দেখান -
This is essentially similar (if more elegantly put) to what Mario and I have been trying to say in our recent collabroative work (e.g. http://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/1059712317710496 … and https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11229-017-1386-z …). However we frame this just in terms of computation, rather than representation.
এই থ্রেডটি দেখান -
I actually now think that the representation question might just be a red herring, as the enactivist/autopoietic objection to (mental) representation is really more of a metaphysical issue than it is a cognitive scientific one.
এই থ্রেডটি দেখান -
I still think that 'rich' attributions of representational content to cognitive systems often obscure more than they explain, but if people want to use representational language in a much thinner or technical sense then I'm not really so concerned.
এই থ্রেডটি দেখান -
Part of this also has to do with my slide towards explanatory perspectivalism/pragmatism, but we're getting off track now. The main point is just that I think Grush is absolutely right that enactivism can fruitfully incorporate computational mechanisms, and vice versa.
#MicDropএই থ্রেডটি দেখান
কথা-বার্তা শেষ
নতুন কথা-বার্তা -
-
-
I got sent this today and I was actually surprised at how many useful points were made in a simple review. On the other hand I was also surprised at how positive it was.
ধন্যবাদ। আপনার সময়রেখাকে আরো ভালো করে তুলতে টুইটার এটিকে ব্যবহার করবে। পূর্বাবস্থায়পূর্বাবস্থায়
-
লোড হতে বেশ কিছুক্ষণ সময় নিচ্ছে।
টুইটার তার ক্ষমতার বাইরে চলে গেছে বা কোনো সাময়িক সমস্যার সম্মুখীন হয়েছে আবার চেষ্টা করুন বা আরও তথ্যের জন্য টুইটারের স্থিতি দেখুন।