Student loan debt forgiveness likely has a multiplier close to zero.
Forgiveness is taxable. If this negative cash flow effect outweighs interest savings would even be net negative. And wealth effect small in short run.
Arbitrary/regressive $1T for ~$0 GDP, not a great idea.
Conversation
Replying to
Note, many considerations in this policy. I was not implying that short-run GDP was the only or even the main one. Many others were listing that as a/the major reason so wanted to help clarify thinking on it. And in a deeply depressed economy that is an important consideration.
25
13
202
Replying to
What about student debt forgiveness for those with incomes under a threshold?
Also, what's the evidence that the consumption impact of an unanticipated debt forgiveness for someone earning 50k/year with say a 50k debt is small?
22
4
180
Replying to
We generally think of wealth effects as 2-5%.
For lower income we think they’re dwarfed by cash flow effects.
The cash flow effects would be negative for many, positive for some.
No idea if it could be tailored. Even if so multiplier at most 0.05 I would guess.
6
2
40
Replying to
Can you not? The cancellation will not be taxable.
Pls just leave this to impacted advocates.
I want dignity—dignity your economic advice deprives me of.
22
15
357
Replying to
Dude. Exempt it from tax in the legislation. Problem solved.
It's easy for a Harvard professor to create a fantasy abt it being a small "wealth effect" bc you're not struggling to pay your rent. This is not a thought experiment for young ppl forced to mortgage their future.
7
Can we structure loan forgiveness to create healthier incentives for universities going forward?
For example, record it as "debt" owed by the corresponding institutions, and require repayment (on reasonable terms) in order for future students to be eligible for loans.
1
2
Replying to
Pontificate all you like but this has been studied well and the long term ROI is absolutely immense, not negligible.
2
2
115
Lmfao.
read image description
ALT
1
Replying to
You’re proving my hypothesis that no one who worked for Obama has ever done anything for the betterment of humanity.
1
3
48







