Those that stayed up often seemed to be overbuilt. So you were really depending on the intuition—and the risk tolerance—of the chief engineer.
-
-
Show this thread
-
How did this persist for so long? How did we get Bessemer steel, electric generators, transcontinental railroads, antiseptics, power looms, adding machines, the telegraph, and canals that divided continents… before we figured out how to build bridges that don't collapse?
Show this thread -
Read that footnote again. Forty bridges a year! That's almost one a week. Like the Sunday newspaper could almost have a regular “bridge collapses” section.
Show this thread -
And bridges are something we've been doing for a long, long time. I think even pre-state societies build simple bridges. The Romans must have built some big ones, no? Did theirs collapse too?
Show this thread -
Plus the math here ought to go back to Newtonian physics, I would think. Basic concepts of force and mass… some of the first to be quantified. Why wasn't there more theory to be applied here?
Show this thread -
Maybe the problem wasn't in making a bridge that could stand, but in all the many random things that could bring it down. Bridges are subject to wind and water, and fluid dynamics is terribly complicated.
Show this thread -
Or to take another example, I think I recall hearing about a failure due to iron becoming brittle in extreme cold, not necessarily something you could predict without a lot of materials science.
Show this thread -
Also I have to admit I have no idea how many total bridges there were in the country at the time, or how fast they were going up. So I don't even know the order of magnitude of the failure rate here. Still, forty a year!
Show this thread -
Anyway, gotta be a fascinating story here. Definitely will cover this in a future
@rootsofprogress post! Subscribe to get it when I do:https://rootsofprogress.org/subscribeShow this thread -
So here's an example of a bridge collapse. Diagnosis: the engineer “had not calculated his wind loads accurately”pic.twitter.com/uwtmofMx9U
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.