Hmm 🤔… “reluctant to send papers they’d have previously given and chance” “to protect the authors from public criticism” sounds to me like REs are still not buying into the new model. If a journal gave me that as an excuse, I’d honestly never go back to it.
Quote Tweet
Replying to @mbeisen @MadS100tist and 3 others
Third, some REs are reluctant to send papers that they previously would have "given a chance" under the old eLife model if they think the reviews will be critical in order to protect the authors from public criticism.


































