I'm not anti-transhumanism, it's just that most ways in which transhumanism is envisioned really aren't an upgrade from being human. "I'd like a tail' for example means you can't use a lot of chairs. There's little point in talking about the metaphysics.
probably the solution is similar to the prokaryote -eukaryote difference: the "post human" isn't likely to be inhuman at all, but human-plus-something else, and very likely they will be visibly indistinguishable (or mostly) - consider what happens in Dune
-
-
For fun: Riemannschneider's Universal Robots Scale, the "L" scale, L may stand for "level", unclear. It goes from 0-7 (it's three bits.)
Show this thread -
L0: Tool/Part - converts some kind of work into another kind of work, like a wheel, or a hammer. L1: Robot Toy - designed to demonstrate a function, such as a mechanical arm, a mouse that walks, etc. True Mechanical Turks are L1's
Show this thread -
L2: Apparatus - an L1 that does real work, like a steam engine, a pump, a bicycle, a clock L3: Spare Hand - an L2 that does one function, and is not directly moved by a human (i.e. robot arms in factories)
Show this thread -
L4: Spare head - an L3 that has multiple functions, it need not do physical work (i.e. a 'smart' phone) L5: Companion - an L4 that adapts to its environment and can assume new functions
Show this thread -
L6: Spare Man - an L5 that is able to maintain itself L7: "Orphan" - Speculative category; an entity that is both completely a man and also a robot, RUR has never successfully produced an L7.
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.
