Notice how Bark's son emphasizes that her mother had lived "the most healthy lifestyle one can live " but got cancer anyway, and a nasty one at that. Correct. Unfortunately that happens. A lot. 2/
-
-
Show this thread
-
Also unfortunately, the message from so much alt med is that if you do the right things, easy the right foods, live the right lifestyle, take the right supplements, you'll be healthy, with the subtext that if you become ill you must not be living and eating right. 3/
Show this thread -
Similarly, in alt med, disease is always caused by something external. Vaccines cause autism, not genes. Environment and lifestyle cause cancer, not genes and/or bad luck, and you can alter these external factors to prevent illness. 4/
Show this thread -
In antivax circles, even in the case of diseases caused by pathogenic organisms, the belief is that a healthy diet and lifestyle will boost your immunity so that disease won't harm you, at least not long term, and, hey, "natural immunity" from the disease is better anyway. 5/
Show this thread -
Remember the time that time years ago when
@billmaher said he didn't need the flu vaccine because his immune system was so good because of his healthy lifestyle? 6/Show this thread -
The best thing was that in response, Bob Costas rolled his eyes and said, "Oh, come on, Superman!" 7/https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/oh-come-on-superman-bill-maher-and-western-medicine/ …
Show this thread -
In any event, it saddens me that Toni Bark's son so clearly buys into the mindset that healthy people living super healthy lifestyles don't get cancer and thus felt obligated to emphasize so much that it's an "unlucky case of a genetic/immunological fuckup." Well, yes it is. 8/
Show this thread -
The problem is that so much alt med has a near-absolutist view regarding our ability to prevent disease and alt med's ability to cure it, such that if you get sick you think it's your fault and if your treatment doesn't work you think it's because you're not doing it right. 9/
Show this thread -
It's the mindset. The message is that you have near total control over your health. The dark flip side of that message is that if you get sick you must have done something wrong. That dark side increases the suffering of cancer patients and those who love them. 10/
Show this thread -
The point is, yes, healthy living and diet can definitely reduce your risk of getting sick, but not to anything near zero. They can also slow the deleterious effects of aging, but we all still eventually age and die anyway, no matter what. 11/
Show this thread -
We have a lot of control over our overall health but nowhere near much as "wellness" gurus claim, and for some specific diseases none at all. Far more often than we'd like to admit,bad luck and genetics can easily trump healthy living. 12/
Show this thread -
I hope that Toni Bark survives get cancer with minimal suffering. It's a nasty kind of cancer. I also hope that she learns from it that health and disease are far more complex than her "holistic health" beliefs. 13/
Show this thread -
I also hope her son doesn't continue with his messaging like this and learns to accept that it's usually not your fault of you get cancer. 14/14
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.