honestly, aside from the institutional racism, creeping fascism, cronyism, cruelty, lack of accountability and violence, I think a major problem with policing is that we consider solving murders, responding to domestic crises and mediating on-the-spot disputes to be one job.
-
-
do we still need people to respond to and handle violent and organised crime? yeah, sadly! the human race kinda sucks on that front! but, dear god, it should be a WAY more specialised, highly trained, transparently monitored, sparsely deployed and FUCKING SELECTIVE JOB that now!!
Show this thread -
here's the other thing, though: policing is what it is in large part because our notion of justice is vastly more vested in punishment and incarceration than in reparations and rehabilitation. there's no point swapping cops for social workers if jail is still the go-to.
Show this thread -
what the fuck does jail do? it takes a bunch of ppl whose crimes vary from serial rape & murder to petty theft & fraud, and puts them all in a big cage under the control of people and corporations who are, let's be real here, almost cartoonishly sadistic and evil. that's it.
Show this thread -
long term, this accomplishes literally nothing but a) more violence and abuse; b) a high rate of recidivism, because almost nothing is done to help reform or rehab even the mildest offenders, who are then pushed out of most jobs on release; c) a market for prison labour -
Show this thread -
- which, best case scenario, means prison corps can undercut companies that could provide real work & wages by "paying" their workers a pittance & thus saving $$, and worst case is actual, literal slavery, which is still legal in the US if in punishment for a crime. seriously.
Show this thread -
it wasn't that long ago that US prisons were "volunteering" their inmates to fight wildfires in california, some of them juvenile institutions; no inmates were paid, nor did they earn any credits/training that would help them become firefighters on release.
Show this thread -
and lest you think "ah, but I'm not American, my prison system doesn't work like that, we're fine!" please be aware that many of the other issues I'm outlining with What Policing Is still apply! yes, even in your progressive country! because it's STILL A LOCKED-IN SYSTEM.
Show this thread -
anyway, it's late and I'm cranky, but there is literally no good goddamned reason for policing & prisons to function as they do except that we've always done it kinda that way, and now it all looks Too Hard to change without admitting the degree to which We Really Fucked Up.
Show this thread -
but, as the saying goes, the best time to change was yesterday; the second-best time is now. just remember that progress with a locked-in system won't always be linear or flawless, and that sometimes, ripping the whole goddamn thing out by the roots might just be your best bet.
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.