Parallel to death of the author, I propose the term monofantheism, which is when fans get so enraged at a creator’s refusal to legitimate a particular headcanon that they forget having a plurality of headcanons is the *point* of fandom & declare the creator unfit to keep canon.
-
Show this thread
-
Listen: once upon a time, you couldn't just hit up the creator of your fave thing on twitter and ask them for extra details about the thing they made! And it's super cool that this can happen now - but only when people aren't dicks about it! Which includes both creators AND fans-
1 reply 34 retweets 345 likesShow this thread -
- but not in the way some fans seem to think, where a creator refusing to endorse their fave interpretation - for the simple reason that doing so *sets it above other fan interpretations and alienates fans who feel differently* - is a sign that The Creator Is Hostile To Fandom.
1 reply 19 retweets 283 likesShow this thread -
So now you've got creators trying to engage with fans from all different perspectives on a good faith basis, only there's fans explicitly looking to take any comments they make in *bad* faith, because it's Not The Right Take, and if they didn't get THEIR answer, no one can!
1 reply 21 retweets 265 likesShow this thread -
A common example of this is conflating a brief response made to a single individual with a blanket, all-encompassing take on a related topic. For instance: Creator says they didn't write Character X as gay, therefore Creator is a homophobe! Like I'm just. YOU GUYS.
1 reply 31 retweets 277 likesShow this thread -
Unless that statement is followed up by some Actual Homophobic Bullshit (TM) such as "this sort of character can never be gay" or "being gay is bad", all you're doing is making a deliberately bad faith leap based on a perfectly neutral - and factual! - statement.
3 replies 16 retweets 267 likesShow this thread -
Just. I am So Tired of seeing people wax lyrical about the transformative power of fannish imagination in one breath, and then SCREAMING in the next that If My Ship Isn't Confirmed As Canon Signed In Triplicate The Creators Must Hate All Queer People And Especially Me Personally.
8 replies 167 retweets 526 likesShow this thread -
Replying to @fozmeadows
Do you think to some degree this runs parallel to the "depiction = approval" crowd? Not to say that things *can't* be troubling or problematic ofc but some people seen to be very eager to do this in (apparent) bad faith
1 reply 0 retweets 6 likes
I think there's probably some overlap, just in terms of both bad and bad faith analysis: the former where people can't distinguish between depiction and endorsement, and the latter where they decide to conflate the two to support a specific argument.
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.