Historically, there have been two opposing views of cognition. One in which intelligence is a general ability to learn from arbitrary data, and one in which intelligence is the result of a myriad of special-purpose systems shaped by millions of years of evolution.
-
-
According to the first view, the mind could be seen as a "blank slate" (or a randomly initialized neural network) capable of making sense of any problem or environment, without requiring hard-wired priors.
Show this thread -
If you take this PoV, a freshly initialized human brain placed in the body of an octopus-like creature living in the higher layers of Jupiter's atmosphere would have no issue taking control of the sensorimotor capabilities of the alien body, socialize with other octopii, etc.
Show this thread -
..and would perhaps end up building an advanced technological civilization, and spread to the rest of universe. In this view, such a thing as "artificial general intelligence" could exist, and a human brain would be an example of it.
Show this thread -
According to the second view, the mind is a collection of advanced cognitive processes hard-wired by evolution, and being merely tuned through embodied experience. Humans' ability for language, for ex, would be an evolved prior, something that thinkers like Chomsky have defended.
Show this thread -
Importantly, it has been at least 15 yrs since we've gathered enough evidence to rule out both views. Although the second view has largely fallen out of favor, the first view is, shockingly, still going strong among people who have no context on the history of cognitive science.
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
The first view can also arise from discovering a mechanism of intelligence that has that property..
Thanks. Twitter will use this to make your timeline better. UndoUndo
-
-
-
Incidentally, a special purpose intelligent problem solving machine will naturally evolve into a general purpose one, not least because doing so involves becoming simpler not more complex.
Thanks. Twitter will use this to make your timeline better. UndoUndo
-
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.