The govt (in a bid to rebut @MalwareTechBlog's arg that wiretap law doesn't apply to foreigners) is here arguing that selling malware amounts to procuring a person to wiretap.
https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/4441094-Brief-in-Opposition-to-Motion.html …
That arg could do interesting things to the Spyware industry. cc @josephfcox
-
-
Show this thread
-
This seems to indicate that the informant the government has been trying to hide by calling a tipster is in CA.pic.twitter.com/9ZRfWPjYH8
Show this thread -
Advertising on YouTube = crime against America. (If they're going to argue THAT why not try this in a venue w/actual cyber prosecutors? Never mind.)pic.twitter.com/g53rOY4tXt
Show this thread -
Hello security researchers!! Here the govt is arguing that SHARING malware w/someone in the US may constitute wiretapping.pic.twitter.com/fOzqHYbmqs
Show this thread -
I'm being an asshole but I find this typo, "overact," funny.pic.twitter.com/lZGcvCDkN2
Show this thread -
.
@MalwareTechBlog: Show us the 10 computers damaged under CFAA. Govt: No.pic.twitter.com/C4MKGzVipf
Show this thread -
Hey
@OrinKerr: EDWI just called you device argument (which@MalwareTechBlog adopted) "convoluted." Fighting words.pic.twitter.com/xW41gYN5La
Show this thread -
You always gotta laugh when the *US* govt relies on an OED definition, not Merriam Webster, to support their word games. MW def ls: "software designed to interfere with a computer's normal functioning."pic.twitter.com/9JokghI6jL
Show this thread -
I expect before we're done govt will say, "Welp, Hutchins is British so of COURSE he takes his understanding of a word that is part of his alias, malware, from the OED. But we also expect him to understand US Miranda rights."
Show this thread -
I'm confused.
@MalwareTechBlog is primarily accused of manufacturing malware. But not even his malware-sending defendant was wiretapping.pic.twitter.com/po5cOxT4er
Show this thread -
Malware is a device because it was advertised on YouTube.pic.twitter.com/u2et9KiNjL
Show this thread -
Page 10 of the brief spends an entire page digging through dictionaries for a definition that helps the govt. https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/4441093-Brief-in-Opposition-to-Motion.html … As someone w/a PhD in language games, even I find this ridiculous.
Show this thread -
In a brief that spends 1.5 pages pointing to definitions in online dictionaries and related reference materials, USG says to ignore what
@MalwareTechBlog says about online dictionaries.pic.twitter.com/uY6fzEj3io
Show this thread -
I'm NAL. But aren't lawyers supposed to cite the relevant case law when they make assertions like this?pic.twitter.com/6lSC56pAHd
Show this thread -
Interjection: Yes, the government (more specifically, non-specialist prosecutors from Wisconsin) is actually malware-splaining to a guy named
@MalwareTech.Show this thread -
.
@MalwareTechBlog, a second time: Please show me the 10 computers damaged under CFAA. USG (after having said "no" once): Let me redefine that as "how malware works." https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/4441092-Brief-in-Opposition-to-Motion.html …pic.twitter.com/UrMSxdszTm
Show this thread -
Note: elsewhere in this package of briefs, the govt says
@MalwareTechBlog tried to dismiss the indictment when he should have asked for a Bill of Particulars. Here, they're saying he can't have a Bill of Particulars.Show this thread -
Aside from the other dickish aspects of this passage (not least that
@MalwareTechBlog never claimed he didn't understand English), the swipe "self-proclaimed" is pretty obnoxious. Also, what does attending DefCon have to do with understanding English?pic.twitter.com/Busy8ZubkO
Show this thread -
USG has *just* made a big deal out of whether someone does or does not understand English. But here, they're suggesting
@MalwareTechLab should have taken the question, "Are you drunk?" to mean, "Are you drunk, doped, or tired?"pic.twitter.com/JhCfKUlrKs
Show this thread -
And fin.
@MalwareTechLab has a hearing today that I won't attend bc I've escaped to the UK, where the weather actually is nice, not like MI and WI. As@nycsouthpaw said, he's likely to lose the Miranda challenge, bc Miranda has withered and died. But that's setup for trial.Show this thread -
But those briefs on device/wiretap/those elusive 10 computers that got damaged? Hoo boy. Which may be why they've decided to go the superseding route.
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.