Andrew EllardVarmennettu tili

SW-TLJ: Rey is living through your expectations. Haunted by them. She’s struck the same way by the reveal. Rey was always the girl who had seen Star Wars as kid. Pilot dolls and heroic myths. Of course she thought she was a secret Skywalker. Didn’t we all? #tweetnotes

SW-TLJ: But how canny is this: LUKE HAS GONE AWAY AND WATCHED THE PREQUELS. He dreamed of being a pilot, a Jedi. Then he found out what a bunch of dicks they were. He watched the DVDs. And he quit. #tweetnotes

SW-TLJ: For fans who think invention is lightsabers being purple, double-ended, four at a time, etc. - or just fans reconciled to the prequels - this is painful stuff. Rey saw the OT and wanted to live that life. Luke saw the PT and realised the Jedi were bullshit. #tweetnotes

SW-TLJ: Luke is right. Prequel Jedi are pricks. Their no love rule is idiocy. Their nonsense should not be tolerated. After Phantom Menace we all wanted to live on Ahch-to and get off our faces on blue milk. #tweetnotes

SW-TLJ: Next problem, for some, will be time. Almost none elapses between The Force Awakens and The Last Jedi. everything over the two films is a matter of days We’re gonna call this The Quantum of Solace Problem. #tweetnotes

SW-TLJ: One of the reasons QoS bugs people is that it that the final scenes of Casino Royale felt like enough ‘getting over it’ for Bond. He’s become Bond now, we can fill in the gaps. What’s all this ‘finding solace’ stuff? #tweetnotes

SW-TLJ: Likewise, we’d decided Rey, Finn and Poe were bonded. We’d got our new hero team, and Kylo was our baddie. What’s all this still-conflicted, still-finding-each-other stuff? #tweetnotes

SW-TLJ: Had this film been set months after TFA, what would we have assumed? Finn’d join up, Rey’d be trained, they’d all be pals and Kylo would be a full-on space bastard. Here we get a film where all the stuff we assumed would happen in the gap…happens on screen. #tweetnotes

SW-TLJ: Regular followers know I love Quantum of Solace. I think it makes interesting points well and with skill. I love Last Jedi. It makes interesting points well and with skill. But both films annoy people because they’re…anecdotal. They’re skippable story. #tweetnotes

SW-TLJ: “Rebel scum” is Finn finally picking a side. He never has before, he was just trying to help his pal Rey. It doesn’t play as huge as it should because…damn, did he not pick already? We just kinda figured he must’ve done. #tweetnotes

SW-TLJ: Likewise there’s a weird twitch to Poe introducing himself to Rey at the end of the film. A real “Wait, two films in and they *just* swapped’ names?!” #tweetnotes

SW-TLJ: Of *course* that’s winding people up. Story-wise, it’s a hard thing to swallow. And especially so in a film about leaning not to revere the Jedi, learning to be part of a whole, not just doing what you want. #tweetnotes

SW-TLJ: It’s basically a film committed to holding characters to account beyond genre. Your genre assumptions are not their lives. But people do not like to watch popcorn adventure films feeling that they’ve been in the wrong. #tweetnotes

SW-TLJ: You had huge ideas about Rey’s parents? Tough. Star Wars never made Luke’s dad a mystery, his story was laid out for you…and then revealed as a lie. Though that’s not all on you. It’s also on JJ, who half-mystery-boxed Rey’s origins as a placeholder in TFA. #tweetnotes

SW-TLJ: Similarly, comparisons to Empire are unavoidable. The ‘escape through space’ story intercut with Jedi training and throwing in a rogue’s betrayal make it inevitable. #tweetnotes

SW-TLJ: We know how Empire works: when Luke leaves Dagobah, we’re into act 3. Finale’s coming. But Rey and Kylo aren’t the finale of TLJ. They’re the second half of act 2. The finale’s down on Crait. Because of this, something trips you there. The pace feels off. #tweetnotes

SW-TLJ: (That’s also to do with a two-hour film somehow being 150 minutes long, of course.) #tweetnotes

SW-TLJ: When you feel the pace wobble in the second half of TLJ, that Empire vibe is part of why. It’s not doing ‘what it should’ based on our experience. #tweetnotes

SW-TLJ: That’s partly on us for bringing such expectations, and partly on the film for being just a bit too much like The Empire Strikes Back. #tweetnotes

SW-TLJ: This is why the film is so, so much better on rewatch, once you know what it’s trying to do. Cos it’s doing it well. It’s just struggling to reverse out of your - and its own - comparisons. #tweetnotes

SW-TLJ: Once you know Poe story’s angle, oh wow is it all tuned-in and tied togther. It’s really precise, so many lines and moments are about teeing it up and paying it off. We were just too annoyed to Holdo to notice. #tweetnotes

SW-TLJ: Don’t get me wrong, that’s a hard one to tell an audience of wannabe flyboys - don’t be so damn rebellious. We have huge human sacrifices in the film, but each is its own calculation. It’s a plea to make calculations. And to trust wiser heads. #tweetnotes

SW-TLJ: In an era of people voting for dumber heads cos they like the myths they tell better than objective reasoning, that seems especially important to be saying. #tweetnotes

SW-TLJ: So I see the issues. I get why “Your parents are normal” is a lesser reveal *than* a reveal. Why “obey your superior” is less fun than “go for it, dude!” Why “Jedi suck” is harder to swallow when you bought a ticket to the lightsaber show than “Jedi rock!” #tweetnotes

SW-TLJ: And - this was the big one for me - why Luke returning and not hugging Leia is less fun then seeing the pair joyously reunited. But the reasons I didn’t get that - why we didn’t get all those things - made this whole film so much more *interesting*. #tweetnotes

SW-TLJ: Those delights would have been hollow calories. The arguments and complexities being offered here are far richer. (And fit far better what the OT actually said and did.) #tweetnotes

SW-TLJ: And it’s not like you don’t get awesome action, characters and jokes. This ain’t ‘eat your greens’. #tweetnotes

SW-TLJ: And as a bonus we get ‘Hey, maybe less of the belief in religious nutjobs who tell you what rules the books insist on, and a bit more actual spirituality, huh?’ #tweetnotes

SW-TLJ: Even the one thing I didn’t love - Canto Bight - is one I have to admit means so much that its prequel aesthetic - all greenscreen riding and CGI smashery - has to be forgotten. Cos to smash that place, to look at who profits, to meet that stable boy? Magic. #tweetnotes