At the end of a paper titled "The Futility of Decision Making Research", in which Weiss and Shanteau reflect on the uselessness of their research careers, the authors take a side-swipe at the Naturalistic Decision Making research community.
Which, what? sciencedirect.com/science/articl
Conversation
Replying to
I mean everyone shits on Kahnemann and co. about many results not replicating, but is there a similar effort to test and replicate RPDM etc.? One frustration I have with that field (but maybe just haven't read enough) is that the answer to "how to make better decisions"...
2
3
Replying to
Oh, actually Kahneman's work DOES replicate well. That critique of Thinking Fast and Slow is simply Chapters 3 and 4, which aren't work by Kahneman et al, and that which Kahneman admits he would have left out if he were writing TFaS again today.