There are four categories of responses to this type of article. Each of these correspond to one of the four classical theories of truth. Let's examine each of them in turn, as an exercise in critical thinking.
Conversation
The first response is to evaluate the argument based on its argumentative structure. Do the conclusions flow logically and coherently from the premises? Are there inconsistencies or logical fallacies in the reasoning?
This is the coherence theory of truth.
1
The coherence theory of truth states that a claim is true if it is logically coherent with all of its upstream propositions.
Basically, the whole 'Socrates is a man, all men are mortal, therefore Socrates is mortal shebang.'
On this basis, Milo's piece passes the bar for truth.
3
2
Replying to
I recognise this from my old philosophy class in Uni. Though the term used to describe this quality is “valid”
An argument can be valid/coherent but still be false because premise is false.
If it’s not coherent or invalid it’s definitely false
1
1
What I’m trying to say is I agree with u on this but I kinda prefer my professor’s terms over your coherence theory of truth
As for progressive summarization, I’m less certain than before abt its importance but I won’t go as far as totally denounce it as completely useless
1
1
Replying to
I would love to hear your notes. What have you found that worked for you, and what have you found that didn't?
2
Replying to
Hmm I’ll say picking the right book/article/video and struggling with it is many times more impt than PS the activity itself.
This is based on the pragmatic theory of truth as you define it
1
1
Sorry I half tipsy I continue tomorrow hahaha
I forgot what I was supposed to say next before I got into car
1
1
PS can be A good way to struggle with the material after which said struggle you emerge being more versed in the material.
Is it THE only effective way? Highly unlikely
Best way regardless context? Less unlikely
Best way for some contexts? Sure
1
1
There are 2 more things I want to add abt PS I cannot recall
Maybe tomorrow
1
Replying to
We can also bookmark this and talk it over during lunch next week. ;)
Replying to
Good point.. I will dog ear a note in case I recall what I wanted to say instead