Cedric Chin on Twitter: "@KimStacks @xmjEE Could you post a screenshot of the original citation in the book? 🙏" / Twitter

I've been struggling with the notion that expertise is 'simply' pattern matching. And yet it seems to have resulted in better learning outcomes in the previous year. A reflection on the challenges of this belief:

commoncog.com

Expertise is ‘Just’ Pattern Matching

I find it a little difficult to believe that expertise is 'merely' pattern-matching. And yet it seems to have resulted in the some of my best learning outcomes over the past year. A look at my...

2

4

6

KimSia Sim (I tweet business & software stuff)

@KimStacks

Jan 21, 2020

Replying to

@ejames_c

I have the book working minds by beth crandall and inside it cites a 2004 paper by Klein and Militello and they distinguish 5 key elements that distinguish experts from beginners. there’s one element that resonates with your concepts of pattern matching. /1

2

KimSia Sim (I tweet business & software stuff)

Replying to

and

Note I have not tried to read any of the paper cited /2

1

KimSia Sim (I tweet business & software stuff)

Replying to

and

/3

1

KimSia Sim (I tweet business & software stuff)

Replying to

and

Ok my bad 2 of the 5 elements cited pattern and they are in this picture: perceptual skills and sense of typicality /4

1

KimSia Sim (I tweet business & software stuff)

Replying to

and

and finally /5

1

KimSia Sim (I tweet business & software stuff)

Replying to

and

PS: if you know how to get those cited papers, i would love to know how and read them in greater detail. Thanks

1

Replying to

and

whats the doi?

2

KimSia Sim (I tweet business & software stuff)

Replying to

and

I couldn’t find the DOI. My best search led me to a chapter in 100plus dollar book in google scholar. where of course you don’t get to see the whole chapter books.google.com.sg/books?hl=en&lr

1

KimSia Sim (I tweet business & software stuff)

Replying to

and

It should look like this.

1

Replying to

and

Could you post a screenshot of the original citation in the book? 🙏

8:57 AM · Jan 25, 2020Tweetbot for iΟS

KimSia Sim (I tweet business & software stuff)

Replying to

and

Klein, G., and L. Militello. 2004. The Knowledge Audit as a method for cognitive task analysis. In How professionals make decisions, edited by H. Montgomery, R. Lipshitz, and B. Brehmer, 335–342. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum & Associates. in Crandall, Beth. Working Minds

1

Replying to

and

Thank you!

1

Conversation