lets explore the concept of morality and culpability! are some animals capable of sin?
-
-
-
If a person carefully plans drug use and isolates themselves from the world as well as anyone is able, but somehow someone else makes it into their space while they are under the influence and as a result the person on drugs does something horrible to the other Is that a sin?
Show this thread -
Imagine that you believe IQ is real Whats your approximate cutoff for culpability being an appropriate concept?
Show this thread -
Are smarter people sinning harder when they commit the same sin as someone who is relatively dull?
Show this thread -
Bedbugs reproduce via obligate traumatic insemination If we uplifted them but changed nothing else about them, would their reproduction be a sin
Show this thread -
-
Do significant classes of sins exist now that did not exist in the past?
Show this thread -
I like polls like this not because I have opinions about the answers (I typically dont!) but because it lets you evaluate the implications of a bunch of potential frameworks and just see how far any given train goes down the line
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
Oh don't forget the golem automata, they also help determine these questions (you must consult your local orthodox rabbi tho not just poll Twitter)
-
I would love to hear them answer but I also am getting a lot of value just imagining these questions :)
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.