Thread on Amazon location decisions.
-
-
For their part, cities hosting Amazon plants can often expect to benefit from their presence. Amazon is large enough that it spawns entire tech ecosystems where it hires, and knowledge spillover in dense urban areas is a well-documented phenomenon.
Show this thread -
In the short run, Amazon can choose where to open these facilities, and has every incentive to request tax advantages from host cities. Cities basically compete with tax breaks in order to obtain. secondary benefits from Amazon. This is *probably* healthful and efficient.
Show this thread -
In the long run, Amazon is at a disadvantage in dealing with regulation. Once it has made a large fixed investment in a city, it may face substantial costs to relocate. A city may be able to extract large concessions from Amazon with less resistance, at that point.
Show this thread -
For example, Seattle tried to deploy a (my view) punitive tax on Amazon recently. The city council was particularly cack-handed about this, and ended up withdrawing the measure; but it's illustrative of the sort of power a city might try to deploy against an incumbent firm.
Show this thread -
HQ2 reads to me as Amazon's attempt to deal with this longer-term political risk in several ways. First, it's a strike at Seattle specifically for lashing out at Amazon. Further, it sends a message to other jurisdictions that attempts at extraction will be rebuffed forcefully.
Show this thread -
Finally, it gives Amazon additional flexibility in the allocation of its workforce. If a city attempts extraction in the future, Amazon can (more easily) move existing or future jobs to another location. This may deter extraction attempts.
Show this thread -
Amazon is a large enough target at this point that it needs to seriously consider political risks, and HQ2 seems to me (casually observing) to be a smart way of doing this.
Show this thread -
My hunch given the media reaction is that doing it so *publicly* was a bad move. Everyone hates big firms, apparently, and if they're concerned about political risks the best move might be to stay low-key. The big stick would have been enough. /thread
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.