I will say, it is VERY INTERESTING to see that all the conservative money, including money to Littman and money to detrans groups, has not so far ended up funding a really robust look at the numbers here.https://twitter.com/e_urq/status/1371877142917681154 …
-
-
If you found something like ROGD among detransitioners and DIDN'T find it among trans people, then you'd have something. Not much, since you'd still have no idea how common it is, but something.
Show this thread -
But as far as I can tell, surveying a trans control group doesn't seem to be part of her plan, and you have to ask yourself- why? If she;s doing an online survey, just as easy to get trans results as a control group too, right?
Show this thread -
There's 2 reasons a study of detrans ppl wouldn't look for differences btw detrans and trans people: 1. Finding differences undermines a hypothesis that all trans men will detrans. 2. No differences undermines the case for pubertal onset as non-normative for trans men.
Show this thread -
Either way, if you want to actually produce interesting finding about detransitioners you need trans people in your study as controls. I could be wrong, but from her call for participants Littman's doing a survey of detrans ppl w/o trans folks to compare them to.
Show this thread -
(I've said this before, and then as now I am purposefully not trying to prevent her from seeing this critique. If she takes it to heart and does better research because if it that would be a great outcome, as far as I'm concerned!)
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.