Evan Urquhart

Our alien scientist would describe things as they are, and make note of when human cultural values contradicted or simplified as an interesting (or stupid, or funny) example of our cultural idiosyncrasies.

How things really are is that our culture divides people into M and F categories that do not map neatly onto human biology, and created a simplified and idealized version of biology (as in the pioneer plaque) for complex social reasons.https://twitter.com/guan/status/1368175755767783430 …

An alien observer who studied me (or any other medically transitioning binary trans person) could not help but note that I occupy a male social role and share many, though not all, biological male characteristics (deep voice, facial hair, testosterone level).

Not having any human cultural baggage, this alien might note that the status of males like myself is culturally contested, but would group us with males, perhaps with some sort of asterisk (like the word 'trans' before male, if you will).

Of course, the alien themselves would likely have some alien cultural context. So, they might miss my sex completely and categorize me primarily as not-food-producing. Or maybe they're really art conscious and would categorize me as great genius, unrecognized.

Heh. Scientifically, my sex is closer to male than female. And alien observing my life history would likely categorize me as having changed sex (perhaps as having gone from female with an asterisk to male with an asterisk, since I was never fertile or heterosexual).

This has informed where I come down on the question of "What AM sex/gender?"

If I'm culturally male and biologically at least somewhat male, I'm male enough for my purposes. There's no "true" gender that overrides that, either in my deep inner feelings or in idealized culturally ideosyncratic biology texts for children.