Since this seems to be a point of confusion, let's start the day with a brief explanation of how I use terms related to detransition.https://twitter.com/billy_pilgrim85/status/1354056324963827713 …
Show this thread
-
A re-transitioner would be someone who detransitioned and then transitioned again, again for any reason.
Show this thread
A detransitioned woman is much more specific. This describes a member of a small community of detransitioners who believes that either all trans men or the vast majority of trans men are suffering from internalized misogyny...
-
-
...that transition is not an effective treatment for gender dysphoria, that confronting internalized misogyny is, and (usually) that trans women are predatory fetishists and transphobic politics can protect women from both trans women and their own desire to become men.
Show this thread -
I use ex-detransitioner to describe a former member of the detransitioned women's community, regardless of whether they have re-transitioned or not. It's admittedly not the clearest possible descriptor, but the alternatives are very long so that's the shorthand I landed on.
Show this thread -
The ex-detransitioned women I spoke to for my Slate piece (which I think is scheduled to publish today but I don't have final confirmation) are both currently using she/her pronouns but do identify as trans.
Show this thread -
I also know a re-transitioner irl- he's just a binary trans guy who tried to go back to living as a woman for a while, but never had any particular ideology around that.
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
Thats not true at all!!! Thats a blanket statement and many detransitioners do not hate trans people its their own story of why it did not work. They are very important to our community as we can learn from them. Stop spreading false information please
-
Right, which is why I make a distinction between detransitioners generally (some of whom ID as women) and the "detransitioned women's community" who are organized around ideological ground and believe all trans men- including you, Buck, are suffering from internalized misogyny.
- Show replies
New conversation -
-
-
This is just strange. What do you call women who detransitioned if you simply want to differentiate from men who detransitioned, without asserting anything about their beliefs?
Thanks. Twitter will use this to make your timeline better. UndoUndo
-
-
-
Thanks for the info.
Thanks. Twitter will use this to make your timeline better. UndoUndo
-
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.